Episode 112: A person has to trust somebody in this world

Yesterday, gruff caretaker Matthew held well-meaning governess Vicki prisoner in his cottage on the great estate of Collinwood. Having inadvertently confessed to Vicki that he killed beloved local man Bill Malloy, Matthew could see no alternative but to kill Vicki. Vicki kept trying to talk him into reassessing his options, but without success. At the end, Matthew had announced his intention to break Vicki’s neck and was choking her. Only when reclusive matriarch Liz entered the room did Matthew stop.

Today, we hear Liz take much the same approach to talking Matthew down that Vicki had tried yesterday. Matthew’s fanatical devotion to Liz keeps him from harming either woman, but his fear of prison drives him to block the exit when they try to leave. As Liz tries to reason with Matthew, we see Vicki’s terrified face between them. Not only does her expression add emotional depth to the scene, but Alexandra Moltke Isles’ resemblance to Joan Bennett drives home the similarity between what Liz is trying now and what Vicki tried in yesterday’s episode. No wonder Vicki is afraid Matthew will attack Liz next.

Eventually Matthew does raise his hands to Liz. She stands her ground. He retreats without touching her. When he menaces her, the music swells; when he backs off, it stops. Then we see Liz in closeup for a couple of seconds before the commercial. That silence makes for one of the most effective act breaks in the whole series.

Back at the great house, Liz and Vicki bring the sheriff and instantly forgettable young lawyer Frank up to date. It’s a lot of recapping, but the actors make it interesting.* Mrs Isles does a particularly good job of seeming bewildered and traumatized. Her lines are repetitive- a lot of “He tried to kill me”- but she delivers them in just the right tone of dreamlike detachment.

Liz’ brother, high-born ne’er-do-well Roger, comes home and is sarcastic to Vicki. Roger had been arrested because he was caught red-handed with some evidence he had hidden from the sheriff, and while in custody had confessed to a series of felonies. This led to him being detained for almost an entire day, an inconvenience for which he blames Vicki. Later, Roger will see Liz and the sheriff in Matthew’s cottage. He insults the sheriff, who is unimpressed. After the sheriff leaves, he demands Liz fire Vicki. Liz tells him that Vicki did nothing wrong and orders him to drop the subject.

I’m not going to bother explaining why Roger thinks Vicki is at fault for his brush with the law. Doing so would require a retelling of the saga of the fountain pen, and no one wants that. Besides, the only person who takes Roger at all seriously today is Vicki, and her attempts to apologize to him come off as a symptom of the extreme confusion she is in after her ordeal. There’s little reason to expect any plot developments to come of Roger’s hostility to Vicki, but Louis Edmonds is always hilarious to watch when he’s playing a character in a snippy mood.

The sheriff has told everyone that Matthew’s old station wagon was seen barreling down the highway toward his brother’s hometown, Coldwater, Maine.** That brings a great relief to Vicki and Liz, but the closing shot of the episode shows us Matthew entering the Old House on the grounds of Collinwood.

This is a fast-paced, well-acted, exciting episode. There is also some good soapcraft in it. The Old House and the caretaker’s cottage have by this point been established as permanent parts of the setting of the series. Matthew’s flight from the caretaker’s cottage leads us to expect that sooner or later a new character will take up residence there, and that there will be a new storyline centering on that character.

Our glimpses of the Old House so far have been tantalizing. We’ve seen the ghost of Josette Collins emerge from her portrait there twice. So we know that it is a place where very strange things are going to start happening one of these days. When we see Matthew go into the Old House, we may well expect that the day will soon be upon us.

*Well, the actors who play Vicki, Liz, and the sheriff do- as Frank, it isn’t Conard Fowkes’ job to be interesting.

**Coldwater, Maine is a fictional place, mentioned only in this episode. It’s a testament to the influence Dark Shadows has had in American popular culture that 56 years after a single reference to it in one of the series’ least-seen segments a significant number of people have heard of Coldwater and are interested in moving there.