Episode 1149: Alive again

Mad scientist Julia Hoffman came unstuck in time in #1109 and found herself in the year 1840. Her best friend, vampire Barnabas Collins, joined her in that year in #1117.

Barnabas is not the only vampire at large in this period. The other is a former woman named Roxanne Drew. At the bidding of wicked witch Angelique, Roxanne has bitten Julia and left her to die. Barnabas finds Julia, who is close to death. Roxanne appears and demands he leave without Julia. He orders Roxanne to look into his eyes. She does, then backs down. Barnabas was the show’s original vampire, and is evidently still the king of his particular hill.

Meanwhile, Flora Collins is entertaining Roxanne’s brother Randall in her home, a mansion known as Rose Cottage. Overbearing undertaker Lamar Trask enters and starts raving about witchcraft and suchlike matters. Jerry Lacy developed a peculiary intense style of performance for the members of the Trask family. After three years of exposure to that style, Joan Bennett is used to it, and keeps it together for her first really good episode as Flora. Up to this point, she’s been doing Flora as an imitation of Millicent Collins, the flighty heiress Nancy Barrett played in late 1967 and early 1968 when the show was set in the 1790s. But between Gene Lindsey’s meticulously understated Randall and Mr Lacy’s maniacal Lamar, Flora emerges as a distinct character. She has a whimsical side and is quick to believe absurdities, but nonetheless is intelligent, decisive, and unintimidated by the imposing men around her.

Lamar gives Flora a Trask-blast, to her amusement. Screenshot by Dark Shadows Before I Die.

Gene Lindsey is new to the show, and he does not hold up so well in the face of Mr Lacy’s onslaught. Randall is supposed to be indignant about Lamar’s callous talk, but Lindsey is stunned and shrinks back. When he delivers Randall’s replies to Lamar, he loses his grip on his lines, stammering and producing forkfuls of word salad such as “Well, if you’re not at liberty to divulge it, why not — say anything at all about it?” After Lamar storms out, Randall has a few more lines with Flora, during which Lindsey begins to recover, and he has some scenes later where he does a fine job. One really can sympathize. Standing face to face with Mr Lacy when he was in full Trask mode must have been like being in a boxing ring opposite a world heavyweight champion.

Out in the woods, Trask meets Roxanne. He is shocked to see her. She bites him.

Barnabas shows up at Rose Cottage with Julia. He tells Flora and Randall to get Julia to bed and put a cross near her. He refuses to answer when Flora asks why they need a cross. He rushes off to fetch a doctor.

Later, Barnabas tells Randall that the doctor has stopped the bleeding and that Julia will have a chance to survive if “the person” who attacked her does not strike again. Randall is puzzled to hear the attacker called a “person,” since everyone has thus far been saying it was an animal. Barnabas breaks the news to him that Roxanne is a vampire. Randall has been away in New York for some time, and so cannot believe in the sorts of things that people in Collinsport have begun to consider possible. After Barnabas shows him Roxanne’s empty coffin, Randall concludes that the story is true.

Barnabas needs help to fight Roxanne. She can be destroyed only in the daylight, which is as fatal to him as it is to her. Flora and Randall are the only people available at the moment. Barnabas does not want to disrupt history in ways that will prevent the world he knew in 1970 from coming into being, and as a member of the Collins family Flora is likelier than Randall to make a vital contribution to the shape of that world. So it is Randall whom he enlists for the dangerous mission.

Flora finds a blissed-out Lamar sitting on her couch. He seems to have only the vaguest recollection of what he had gone on about with such vehemence so shortly before. Flora thinks he must be coming down with a fever.

The function of a Trask is always to attack. When they cease to attack, the Trasks immediately become comic. The first Trask, a fanatical witchfinder with no first name who appeared in the 1790s segment, occasioned some of the darkest black comedy in the series when Barnabas planted a dead hooker in his room. Seeing that the mission which he regarded with such suffocating sincerity would come to an end if the facts were revealed, that Trask turned to an unsavory character for help getting rid of the body. When we saw that gruesome situation tip his earnest fanaticism into base hypocrisy, we could respond only with a grim chuckle.

The second Trask was the Rev’d Mr Gregory Trask, a villain in the segment set in the year 1897 that ran through most of 1969. Gregory was a hypocrite from the beginning. At times he made the opposite move from his forebear. He was sufficiently committed to his act that he occasionally convinced even himself of his righteousness. That wasn’t funny, because it didn’t knock him off the offensive. But when Gregory’s daughter Charity came to be possessed by the ghost of Cockney showgirl Pansy Faye and summoned him by shouting “Hey, Traaaaask!” his discomfiture was enough to make you fall on the floor. The Zen state Lamar seems to be in after Roxanne has bitten him doesn’t raise that kind of guffaw, but I started chuckling right away and just laughed harder at each line.

Randall and Barnabas return. Flora tells them that now she knows why Barnabas insisted they get a cross for Julia, since she has obviously been bitten by a vampire. The men then interact with Lamar and notice his atypical calm. When Lamar hurries out, making a nonsensical excuse, Randall expresses puzzlement. Barnabas says that Lamar must be Roxanne’s new victim, and that if they follow him he might lead them to her.

That’s how it works out. In Roxanne’s tomb, Barnabas apprehends Lamar. He orders Randall to stay. Randall is alarmed that Barnabas won’t be with him, but Barnabas points out that he has to get Lamar out of the way. Roxanne shows up, and Randall uses a cross to keep her away from her coffin as the sun is rising. There is some dialogue between them, and Lindsey gets to show us how reluctant Randall is to do his sister in, even though he knows intellectually that he is freeing her from a curse and allowing her to rest in peace. The episode ends on a cliffhanger. Roxanne is still recoiling from the cross when we cut to the credits, and there is still time for Angelique to intervene before she disintegrates.

This episode is fast-paced and fun to watch, the first such in several days. Since we can’t help but know that the end is approaching for Dark Shadows, the rough patches bring a fear they didn’t earlier in its run. We find ourselves wondering if this is it, if we’ve reached the dregs and there are no enjoyable episodes left. I try to avoid giving spoilers, but I don’t think it will ruin any suspense anyone wants to be in if I say that I seem to remember that the show keeps having its good days for a while yet. There does come a time when they are few and far between, but I don’t think there is any need to fear that the last good episode is behind us.

Episode 1148: A time-honored way to steal your soul

In #1109, mad scientist Julia Hoffman came unstuck in time and found herself in the year 1840. In #1117, her best friend, vampire Barnabas Collins, followed her there.

Now, Julia is trapped in a deserted lighthouse, dying from wounds inflicted on her by a vampire named Roxanne whom wicked witch Angelique controls. Angelique’s henchman Laszlo comes to taunt Julia about her impending death and rising as a vampire. He notices that she is wearing a fine ring, which he promptly steals.

Laszlo goes to the Old House on the grounds of the estate of Collinwood. Barnabas and Angelique are both based in that house. Angelique and Barnabas were once married, and she is forcing him to pretend they still are. Laszlo is looking for Angelique, but Barnabas is the one at home. Laszlo tries to lie his way out of the awkward situation, but when Barnabas sees Julia’s ring on his finger he grabs him by the throat and demands to know where she is. We end with Barnabas letting himself into Julia’s prison and seeing that she appears already to be dead.

Barnabas recognizes Julia’s ring. Screenshot by Dark Shadows Before I Die.

Also in this episode, Quentin Collins has figured out that governess Daphne Harridge is actually the sister of the late Joanna Mills, with whom he had an affair some time before her death. Daphne admits to being Joanna’s sister, and says that she came to the great house at Collinwood with the intention of killing him. She blames him for Joanna’s death. He denies responsibility for this, and she is convinced.

When Daphne first came to Collinwood, someone started leaving notes for Quentin, apparently from Joanna. We actually saw Daphne leave the first of these notes in #1122, and just yesterday Quentin found another such note on the table next to a spot where Daphne had been standing while he wasn’t looking at her. Daphne continues to deny that she is responsible for the notes, and he decides that someone else must be leaving them. He names Joanna’s ghost as a suspect. Another note appears in the drawing room today while Quentin and Daphne are alone there. This one is addressed to Daphne, and she reacts with distress when Quentin reads it to her. The audience knows that the show is mainly about the supernatural, so we may not regard Quentin as a complete idiot. But it still seems pretty obvious that Daphne is leaving the notes.

Episode 1147: We were dead

Quentin Collins hired Daphne Harridge, a woman he had never before met, as governess to his son Tad and to permanent houseguest Carrie Stokes. At just about the time this person he did not know gained access to his house, notes addressed to him started showing up from the late Joanna Mills, with whom he had an affair some time before her death. Today Quentin sets a trap to find who is leaving the notes. Daphne walks in with a note in her hand. He is thunderstruck, since he had not suspected her.

Daphne shows Quentin that the note is addressed to someone else, and he assumes she must be innocent. The moment she leaves the room, he finds that there is now a note on the table next to where Daphne was standing while he was looking at the other note. It would seem obvious that Daphne left that note while he wasn’t looking, but then it has been obvious from the beginning that Daphne was probably behind the notes. So it is no surprise Quentin doesn’t make the connection. By the end of the episode he is beaten over the head with some information that reveals Daphne is Joanna’s sister, which the audience figured out several days ago. When he confronts her with this fact, we wonder if she will be able to make him let go of it as easily as she convinced him she wasn’t leaving the notes.

Daphne doesn’t seem to be significantly brighter than Quentin. She has come to Collinwood intending to murder Quentin. She decides today that before she does that, he will fall in love with her. She gets him to give her a couple of passionate kisses. After that, she is left thinking to herself that she does not share his incipient feelings for her, that her behavior is just part of her plan. If so, her plan is as hopelessly dumb as is Quentin’s failure to put one and one together. Nor is there any sign of intelligence in the dialogue today. It takes a lot to make us dread the sight of actors as appealing as David Selby and Kate Jackson, but this episode manages it.

Daphne and Quentin. Screenshot by Dark Shadows Before I Die.

There is also a scene in which Quentin’s wife Samantha barges in on Daphne’s tutorial with her charges. Carrie and Tad are yelling at each other at the moment Samantha enters. She scolds Daphne for failing to discipline them. By the end of the scene, she is forbidding her to discipline them. Virginia Vestoff is usually as irresistible in her way as Mr Selby and Miss Jackson are in theirs; in this dismal scene, they succeed in making Samantha entirely resistible.

This is the first time we have seen Tad as a living being, and the first time we have seen David Henesy since #1109. Tad is in a foul mood. He doesn’t like anyone he meets. He isn’t clever about expressing his hostility, but simply tries to irritate everyone. He taunts Carrie, defies Daphne, and ignores Samantha. Mr Henesy’s characters have often been the fulcra on which major developments in the story of Dark Shadows have turned. So the very first thing we learned about the menace to the Collins family lurking at the heart of the current segment is that in 1970, Tad’s ghost will take possession of his Doppelgänger, strange and troubled boy David Collins, resulting in David’s death. The journey back in time to 1840 is, therefore, largely an attempt to redeem Tad and rescue David. That might be a significantly more compelling if Tad weren’t such an annoying little shit.

Carrie has received a gift, a crystal ball. The giver was ostensibly seagoing con man Gerard Stiles, a friend of Quentin and sometime lover of Samantha, but in fact Gerard no longer exists. His body is occupied by warlock Judah Zachery, an implacable foe of all the Collinses. We first saw this prop in #48, when it was a gift to David from Burke Devlin. Burke was a former friend of David’s father Roger, sometime lover of his mother Laura, and an implacable foe of all the Collinses.

Carrie looks in the crystal ball. Kathleen Cody is the one member of the cast who is pleasant to watch today, and she does what she can with a speech describing the dark and indefinite forms visible in the crystal changing their shape. But since the camera gives us an unobstructed view of the perfectly transparent glass orb throughout the whole of this speech, the visuals undercut her. When she claims to see herself and Tad lying dead on the floor of the very room in which they now sit, she says that “We look like we did now!,” suggesting that they have little time left, certainly too little for Daphne to teach them correct grammar. A premonition of Carrie and Tad’s deaths harks back to a drum the show beat so heavily in the lead-up to the jump from 1970 to 1840 that regular viewers knew exactly what Carrie would see as soon as she unpacked the crystal ball, and the whole scene is too straightforward to create a dramatically satisfying sense of inevitability. It’s just the same old thing one more time.

Nothing works in this one. It moves incredibly slowly. At the halfway mark, I was astounded the credits didn’t start rolling. It felt like we’d been watching for at least half an hour, and the second half crept by if anything more slowly.

Episode 1146: D is for Daphne. D is also for the Devil.

Warlock Judah Zachery has evicted seagoing con man Gerard Stiles from his body and taken it for himself. None of Gerard’s acquaintances has noticed the difference.

Gerard was angling for the attentions of governess Daphne Harridge, a project Judah is continuing. Today he sees Daphne in the drawing room of the great house of Collinwood. He repels her with his insistence that she will want him. At one point, the expression on his face so terrifies her that she says she cannot imagine ever forgetting it.

Judah’s powers include the ability to send dreams to people. Daphne has a dream in which she is desperately attracted to “Gerard,” and after she awakens she goes back to the drawing room and hangs out with Judah for a little while.

Unknown to Judah, Daphne is not the wholesome innocent she seems to be. She has come to Collinwood vowing to murder Quentin Collins, father of her charge Tad. Shortly after Daphne’s arrival, Quentin started getting notes apparently from Joanna Mills, a woman with whom he had an affair a few years ago. Since Joanna has been dead since last November, this is rather puzzling. The other day, one of these notes instructed Quentin to meet Joanna at a secret trysting place of theirs in the woods. When he got there, he saw Daphne from behind. Her slender figure and long black hair led him to think she was Joanna until she turned around and he saw her face. So we know that Daphne looks very much like Joanna. Before he was replaced by Judah, Gerard had learned that “Daphne Harridge” was likely an alias. It seems that she is Joanna’s sister, that she blames Quentin for Joanna’s death, that this is her motive for wanting to kill Quentin, and that the notes are part of her murder plan. At the end of today’s episode, Quentin catches Daphne with a note.

Daphne caught red-handed. Screenshot by Dark Shadows Before I Die.

There are some memorable moments today. We open in the basement of Collinwood, where Judah has given a terrible shock to Quentin’s father Daniel. As a result, Daniel is having a cardiac episode. Daniel’s second son, Gabriel Collins, enters and asks what is going on. Judah orders him to hurry upstairs and fetch a doctor. Gabriel uses a wheelchair, and the year is 1840. So it is hard to imagine how he got into the basement by himself without attracting attention, and even harder to imagine how he could hurry up a flight of stairs. Gabriel is always turning up on different floors of the house, which the show never explains. But this is an especially laughable example.

Daphne walks in on Quentin when he is drunk. He starts telling her how sad everyone in his family is. When he gets around to mentioning that his father killed his mother, he notices her reaction of shock. He then says mildly that it is a “well-known secret.” Some websites list this as a blooper, but I’m sure it was scripted. Quentin’s dialogue includes many such ironic turns of phrase, and returning viewers will remember that when we saw Daniel in #1110 he introduced himself by raving to the first stranger who came along that he had murdered his wife. The Collinses may be rich enough to keep law enforcement from bringing their patriarch to justice, but their wealth and power also make them the cynosure of everyone in the village of Collinsport. There can’t be many people there who do not know the whole story of Daniel’s killing of Harriet.

When Judah is preparing to cast his spell on Daphne, he intones “D is for Daphne. D is also for the Devil.” James Storm’s style of acting is somewhat like choral singing, in that he finds a single pitch and holds to it throughout each line he delivers. When he is paired with a strong scene partner like Louis Edmonds or Virginia Vestoff or Christopher Pennock, this mode of enunciation can be effective. But it tends to monotony when he has to give a soliloquy, and starting from a line like “D is for Daphne” this speech sounds like a bad parody of Sesame Street. “This episode is brought to you by the number 666!”

Terry Crawford is in a few scenes as Gabriel’s odious wife Edith. Miss Crawford is an extremely nice person, and can do a good job playing a character who is not in any way complex. The moment she has to indicate mixed emotions or show that her character is concealing her true feelings, she goes splat. Her first and last scenes are with Gabriel, and revolve around the possibility that Daniel will change his will in Gabriel’s favor. Edith has nothing to hide from Gabriel, and so Miss Crawford has no trouble in the first scene making it clear that Edith is very greedy and in the last scene making it clear that she regards Gabriel’s disability with contempt. In between, Edith has a scene with Judah, whom she believes to be Gerard. She is at once attracted to “Gerard” and frustrated with him, a combination that defeats Miss Crawford so thoroughly her lines come out as if she were reading each word off a separate fortune cookie slip.

I sometimes wonder if Edith might have been a more fruitful part of the story had she been played by a more accomplished actress. After all, regular viewers know that it is her descendants who will ultimately inherit the Collins fortune, and a much older version of the character made a big impression in March 1969, when the show was set in 1897.

In the 1897 segment, the nonagenarian Edith was played with great verve by Isabella Hoopes. Lisa Blake Richards looked a little bit like a young version of Hoopes, certainly far more than Miss Crawford ever did. Miss Richards played two parts on the show, both women named Sabrina, the first of whom gave her almost nothing to work with, the second of whom was just getting interesting when her storyline came to an abrupt conclusion.

In 1966, Miss Richards made her television debut on WGBH, the educational station in Boston. They broadcast a production of Gertrude Stein’s play “Yes is for a Very Young Man.” The Harvard Crimson‘s 1965 review of the play as performed by the same company had singled Miss Richards out as one of the best in a fine cast that struggled to elevate a bad play, writing that “Lisa Richards as [the protagonist’s] wife does an outstanding job with a whining, pathetic character.” In Miss Crawford’s hands, Edith is also a whining, pathetic character. In the 1897 segment, lady’s maid Beth Chavez was originally supposed to be complex and multilayered. When the writers saw that Miss Crawford couldn’t handle that, they retooled Beth as someone who spoke blunt truths and couldn’t be bothered with nonsense. Perhaps if Miss Richards had taken the part of Edith her abilities might have inspired the writers to come up with something closer to what the audience had a right to expect from such an important figure in the Collins family’s history.

Episode 1145: We must execute with all extreme caution

Dark Shadows is completing the ninth week of a segment set in the year 1840. Like the other episodes of the segment, this one is packed with action, but still seems slow. In part that is because they are in such a hurry to keep the story beats coming that they don’t anchor them in relationships between characters we care about. In part it is because of the drag longtime viewers feel when they see undisguised recycling of stories from previous segments. In part it might be because they spent so much time in the months leading up to the segment teasing developments that haven’t taken place and are pretty clearly not going to take place. And in part it is because of something the original audience would not have known but that today even the viewers most scrupulous about avoiding spoilers cannot help but know, that we are just a hundred episodes from the end of the series. It’s hard to believe that anything much will come of what is happening when we know that that less than 10% of the show remains.

Seagoing con man Gerard Stiles was evicted from his body the other day. The new occupant is warlock Judah Zachery. Judah was put to death by order of magistrate Amadeus Collins in 1692, but he is not one to let a little thing like that slow him down. After 148 years as a disembodied head, he is getting busy with a plan to avenge himself on Amadeus’ descendants.

One of these, Quentin Collins, wants to show off his latest home improvement project to his good buddy Gerard. Not knowing that there is no longer any such person, he takes Judah to the basement of the great house of Collinwood and shows him his “Stairway into Time.” He explains that by going up and down the stairway, a person will be able to go forward and backward in time. He does not explain how this works, but since it is the means by which mad scientist Julia Hoffman brought us from 1970 to 1840 regular viewers know that it does work. Several months ago, the characters found that they could pass into an alternate universe by walking through a door in a little-used hallway of the great house. There was no attempt to suggest any mechanism, either technological or natural or magical, to account for this aperture. Because there was no explanation to consider, we wound up simply accepting the alternate universe as a bare fact. The Stairway into Time is similarly easy to accept.

Quentin shows off the Stairway into Time to Judah, who is masquerading as Gerard. Screenshot by Dark Shadows Before I Die.

Judah, masquerading as Gerard, seems unconvinced. Quentin goes off to get some of the project documents, leaving Judah alone in the basement. He uses the time to cast a spell on overbearing undertaker Lamar Trask. Lamar is sure Quentin is a warlock who murdered a woman named Lorna Bell in the course of a Black Mass. In fact, Judah committed this crime. He sends a dream in which Lamar sees Quentin killing Lorna. When Lamar wakes up, he is sure that he has had a revelation from the Almighty.

Quentin returns to the basement with his papers. Judah is reading them aloud when Quentin’s wife Samantha barges in. She starts telling Quentin that they need to talk about the governess in charge of their son Tad’s education. Then she notices Judah. Thinking him to be Gerard, Samantha falls silent. She looks down, shamefaced, and says she thought Quentin was alone. She hurries out.

Quentin tells “Gerard” that they shouldn’t let Samantha get in the way of their friendship. Until #1120, Samantha and Gerard thought that Quentin and Tad were dead, lost at sea. They married. When Quentin came back, he found the situation amusing, and promised to abide by whatever decision Samantha made about her marital status. It was fine with him when she chose Gerard, but when she said she wanted to take Tad with her the conversation became intensely hostile. When Gerard found out that Samantha wanted to marry him even though she no longer had a claim on Quentin’s inheritance, he quickly made it clear he was not interested. So neither man actually wants Samantha, but Quentin very much regards Gerard as a dear friend. Quentin’s brother Gabriel may have spoken truer than he knew in #1127, when he was taunting Samantha and asked her if she had addressed her son with “Dear Tad, there is something I must tell you. You are going to have two fathers now.” In fact, Quentin and Gerard were co-parenting Tad when their ship ran into trouble, and would probably still be happily doing that now if all had gone according to plan.

Lamar comes to Collinwood and tells Samantha about his dream. She thinks he is an idiot, which of course he is. Nonetheless, she is looking for a way to dislodge Quentin from his father Daniel’s affections. She hopes that Daniel will disinherit Quentin and name Tad as his heir with herself as his guardian. So she sends Lamar along his way with encouragement to keep accusing Quentin of witchcraft.

After a quarrel with Quentin, Samantha tells Daniel what Lamar told her. Daniel marvels that she would listen to anything such a “pompous imbecile” might tell her, but he does remember the events of the 1790s, when he was a boy, and of 1803, when he was 20. There was witchcraft in the area in those periods, and it led to strange and horrible acts of violence. There have been strange and horrible acts of violence lately, some of them uncommonly like the events of those earlier years. So Daniel cannot lightly disregard the allegations against Quentin, despite their ludicrously unreliable source.

Daniel confronts Quentin in the drawing room. He asks “Are you practicing witchcraft in this house?” Quentin is shocked by the question, and rages at Samantha and Lamar for bringing it to Daniel’s mind. Daniel insists Quentin answer, and he says “No, I am not practicing witchcraft in this house.” He really should have omitted the phrase “in this house,” since he does after all have access to many other houses, but that suffices to bring the scene to its conclusion. Quentin goes on to the foyer, where he shouts at Samantha that if she keeps trying to turn Daniel against him he will take great pleasure in strangling her.

Daniel has great faith in Gerard. Judah takes advantage of this. When Daniel tells “Gerard” that he regards him as a man of sound judgment, Judah responds that Quentin is his closest friend and that he could not take Lamar’s charges seriously without far more compelling evidence than has been forthcoming. Daniel brings up Quentin’s Stairway into Time, which he has regarded as a joke but which Lamar has made him suspect might be some kind of product of black magic. Judah offers to show him the stairway and put his fears to rest.

When Daniel sees the stairway, he says that he must have been right. It is simply an ordinary stairway, and Quentin’s talk about time travel can only be one of his peculiar little jokes. He walks up it a bit, and Judah causes him to have a vision of Quentin strangling Lorna. Not only did Daniel likely hear Quentin shouting about how much he would enjoy strangling Samantha, he himself murdered his own wife Harriet by strangulation some years ago and from time to time has fits of madness during which he mistakes other women for Harriet and tries to strangle them. So he knows that his family is a strangley bunch, and believes that what he is seeing is real.

Daniel has a heart condition, and the vision of Quentin strangling Lorna triggers chest pains. This episode marks the final appearance of Lorna and of actress Marilyn Joseph; we may wonder if it marks Daniel’s final appearance as well.

Episode 1144: Lighthouse keeping

In #1109, broadcast and set in 1970, mad scientist Julia Hoffman and her friend, vampire Barnabas Collins, were trapped in the great house of Collinwood while a group of zombies were destroying it and attacking them. Julia escaped by means of an anomaly in space and time that takes the form of a staircase. She found herself in the year 1840.

Since #1063, the show had been building up the ghost of Gerard Stiles as its next supernatural Big Bad. It was at the ghost’s bidding that the zombies destroyed Collinwood. Gerard is alive in 1840, so when Julia realizes what year she has come to she believes that she is about to confront her greatest enemy. But the living Gerard has fizzled completely as a villain. The other day, he was evicted from his body and replaced by the spirit of a dead warlock. James Storm is now playing Judah Zachery, who is impersonating Gerard. The 1840 segment does show more signs of advance planning than do most parts of Dark Shadows, particularly in the costuming, set design, and casting. So it is possible they always meant to do this. But it still feels like Mr Storm was given a new part because the writers couldn’t make Gerard work.

The key witness in the 1692 trial that resulted in the beheading of Judah’s original body is still alive and apparently the same age as she was then. She is wicked witch Angelique Collins, whom Judah knew in 1692 as Miranda DuVal and who is now using the alias Valerie Collins. Judah is not quite certain Angelique is really Miranda, so he causes the ghost of magistrate Amadeus Collins to appear and make the same speech he made to her before she gave her testimony. She recognizes Amadeus, calls him by name, and sends him away. This proves her identity to Judah. He takes satisfaction in the fact that he knows who she is while she does not know who he is.

Angelique is busy with a project of her own. Barnabas managed to follow Julia back to 1840. Angelique was married to Barnabas for a little while in the 1790s, and when their relationship didn’t work out she turned him into a vampire. She wants him back now, and sees Julia as an obstacle to that goal.

Angelique was an enemy to Barnabas and Julia in 1968 and an ally of theirs in 1897 and 1970, but she does not remember any of those times. She is not a time-traveler at this point. It was only yesterday that she learned Julia and Barnabas had come from the future, and she was candid with Julia about how amazing she found it that she and Barnabas had transcended time. Strangely, Julia’s own candor in response to Angelique’s discovery of her origin extended only to the time when they were enemies, not to those when they were friendly.

Angelique sicced vampire Roxanne Drew on Julia. Now, Julia is in an old lighthouse, dying of the wounds Roxanne inflicted on her. Angelique tells Julia today that she is going to let her die and rise as a vampire. Barnabas knows that this is going on, and so he divides his time between searching for Julia and quarreling with Angelique.

Julia waiting to die. Screenshot by Dark Shadows Every Day.

As a kid in the 1970s and 1980s, I spent a lot of time reading Mad Magazine. It really is too bad Mad never satirized Dark Shadows;* James Storm and Lara Parker both had the kinds of faces Jack Davis loved to draw, and today each of them uses facial expressions he could have tipped into hilarity by the slightest exaggeration.

*The first issue of Marvel Comics’ Spoof did do a satire of the show in 1970; the whole feature can be found on Danny Horn’s great blog Dark Shadows Every Day. It’s pretty funny, and writer Roy Thomas makes clever use of so much of the show’s deep lore that he must have been a devoted fan. But, talented as artist Marie Severin was, she was no Jack Davis. Not only was Davis a master of subtle caricature, but he also had a gift for drawing crowded scenes that didn’t look busy. It was a stylistic decision to draw Barnacle Crawlins and the rest of the “Darn Shadows” gang in the very broadly cartoonish manner typical of Spoof, Crazy, and Marvel’s other attempts to compete with Mad. Had Davis been on the job, he would have had to draw them that way as well. But the big scenes with lots of characters are cluttered in a way that Davis’ scenes never were.

Episode 1143: Her life, so different from ours

Vampire Barnabas Collins is doing what he does best, sitting around his house feeling sorry for himself because he has killed someone. In this case the deceased is Roxanne Drew, a young woman with whom he shared a mutual attraction. He had bitten Roxanne and left her for dead, intending that she would rise as his vampire bride and they would spend eternity together preying on the living. This plan was upset when mad scientist Julia Hoffman, MD, found Roxanne and saved her life. Julia is a time traveler who has come to 1840 from 1970, where she and Barnabas are dear friends. When Barnabas bit Roxanne, he was his 1840 self, with no recollection of any of the adventures he and Julia had shared in other periods of history and no compunction about murder. He was about to kill Julia when his 1970 personality infused itself into his 1840 body, bringing with it all of the memories and character development from his years on the show.

Barnabas’ sometime wife, wicked witch Angelique, has returned to the estate of Collinwood and is determined to resume her place at his side. Like Barnabas at the beginning of the 1840 segment, she remembers only the past and has no idea who Julia is. She does not know that she was an enemy of Julia and Barnabas in 1968, or that she was their ally in 1897 and 1970. She does know that Barnabas likes Roxanne more than he likes her, and so she threatened to reopen Roxanne’s wounds and cause her to die and rise as a vampire unless Barnabas left her alone.

When Angelique made that threat, it did not seem to add anything to the story. Barnabas had already resolved to leave Roxanne alone. But when Barnabas heard that Roxanne had agreed to marry overbearing undertaker Lamar Trask, a man he hates, he sent Julia to talk her into breaking the engagement. Roxanne took Julia’s visit to mean that Barnabas wanted to make a life with her, so she called on him at the great house of Collinwood. They were kissing when Angelique walked in on them. Shortly after, Roxanne was telling Lamar they could never marry when Angelique cast a spell to cause blood to start spurting out of her old wounds. She was dead by the time Lamar brought Julia back to examine her. When Roxanne breathed her last, Lamar looked at Julia, declared that her death was Barnabas’ fault, and vowed that he would avenge it.

A knock comes at the front door of Barnabas’ house. He finds a man who introduces himself as Roxanne’s brother Randall Drew, an attorney practicing in New York. Lamar has told Randall of his theory that Barnabas cast a spell that killed Roxanne. Barnabas asks him if he accepts the theory. He does not. He seems persuaded when Barnabas says that Lamar is deranged because Roxanne broke their engagement, and apologizes for troubling him with the story.

I expected Barnabas to take advantage of an opportunity Lamar has given him to solve one of his most frequent problems. He is forever having to make excuses for missing funerals that took place during daylight hours. When Randall tells him what Lamar said, Barnabas could easily have said, “Alas, I shall not be able to attend Roxanne’s funeral, dear as she was to me. It will be held in Mr Trask’s chapel, after all.” It’s true he rarely takes advantages of such opportunities, but for some reason it really annoyed me this time.

Julia enters. Barnabas introduces her to Randall. Randall exits. Julia says that she is sure Randall will have many questions for her before long, but that she is not feeling up to answering an attorney’s questions.

Danny Horn’s post about this episode on his great blog Dark Shadows Every Day is a spoof of the dialogue, giving vent to his displeasure that Randall does not make much of an impression. The post is hilarious, but the objection is unfair. Julia’s remark about an attorney’s questions demonstrates that if he became a substantial part of the show, Randall would turn it into a detective drama. That’s the last thing we need. His function is to support Jonathan Frid’s performance as Barnabas and Virginia Vestoff’s as Roxanne and Randall’s sister, Samantha Drew Collins. To the extent that Randall fades into the background while those dynamic actors take star turns, Gene Lindsey is doing a good job.

Meanwhile, Angelique is snooping in Julia’s bedroom at the great house. She discovers her appointment book from 1970. Annoyed as I was that Barnabas didn’t think fast enough to use Lamar’s unreasoning hostility as an excuse not to make a public appearance in the daylight, I was much more so that Julia would hold onto an object that can do nothing but expose her secret to an enemy.

Poor as Julia’s thinking was when she decided to keep the appointment book, it is if anything even worse when Angelique confronts her with it. At first she claims not to recognize the names in the book. When she finally gives up on that, she tells Angelique only about the period in 1968 when she and Barnabas were Angelique’s enemies, not about the times in 1897 and 1970 when they were allies. It was strange she and Barnabas didn’t try to tell Angelique about those times when she first turned up. It was very much as if Barnabas were still his 1840 self. It has only become harder to explain as time has passed, and in this scene is just inexplicable.

Angelique confronts Julia. Screenshot by Dark Shadows Before I Die.

Since last they met Angelique, Barnabas and Julia did spend some time in an alternate universe. The show insists on calling that universe “Parallel Time.” Angelique’s counterpart in Parallel Time was an implacable foe. When she finally saw through Julia’s masquerade as her own counterpart, who was the housekeeper at Collinwood and her devoted friend, that other Angelique addressed her as “Dr Hoffman,” as this Angelique does today. It would be pretty foolish for Julia and Barnabas to hold a grudge against their Angelique for what her counterpart did in Parallel Time, but they aren’t showing much brainpower today. Maybe that is what they are doing.

Julia intends to go to Roxanne’s tomb and stake her before sunset. Angelique casts a spell to make her fall asleep. She wakes up late in the afternoon and hurries off, but gets to the tomb too late. Roxanne is out of her coffin and bearing her fangs at her. At this conclusion, we wonder just how dim Julia’s bulb is going to get.

Episode 1142: Logic will not give us the answer to this

The severed head of warlock Judah Zachery has at various times been housed in three of the bedrooms in a mansion known as Rose Cottage. Occasionally, it opens its eyes. When it does this, it is played by actor Michael McGuire. At other times, the head is still. In those scenes, a replica of McGuire’s head is used.

Today, Judah takes possession of seagoing con man Gerard Stiles. When he does so, the head closes its eyes forever. Using Gerard’s body as his own, Judah orders his minion Charles Dawson to keep the head in a safe place. McGuire went back to Broadway to appear as Richard Greatham in a revival of Hay Fever.

One of the judges who sentenced Judah to be beheaded in 1692 was Amadeus Collins. Now that he is back in action, Judah wants to take revenge on Amadeus’s descendants. He decides to frame Quentin Collins for witchcraft. The dramatic date is 1840, and the location is the state of Maine. In our universe, there were no laws against witchcraft in Maine or anywhere else in the English-speaking world at that time, and had not been since 1736. But early in 1968, Dark Shadows was set in 1796, and we saw that there were witchcraft laws on the books in its version of the place. So perhaps they are still in effect in 1840.

At any rate, the black magic rite in which Judah implicates Quentin involves a human sacrifice. So even if there are no witchcraft laws, presumably the murder statutes would apply. Judah, passing as Gerard, goes to a viewing at the funeral home operated by overbearing undertaker Lamar Trask. A woman named Lorna Bell shows up to pay her respects to the deceased. As Gerard, Judah tells her that some of his friends are getting together for a Lamar-free memorial service later in the evening. She agrees to attend, and says she wants to go home with him afterward. Quentin stops in, and Lorna sees that he and Gerard are friends. She tells him that she will see him later that evening. Lamar overhears. Quentin doesn’t know what she is talking about.

Lorna goes to a house where Dawson meets her. He ushers her into room with an altar. He locks her in by herself. He returns, and Judah also enters, wearing a mask and carrying a dagger.

Lamar calls on Quentin in the great house of Collinwood. He informs him that Lorna was found murdered, with “the mark of Satan” on her forehead. It turns out that Quentin wears a ring with this mark.

Even if the Dark Shadows version of Maine was in 1840 as lacking in witchcraft laws as was the real one, it would seem rather indiscreet for a prominent member of the community to go around wearing a ring featuring “the mark of Satan.” It may not have been so strange in 1970, when the success of the movie Rosemary’s Baby led to a fad for Satanic symbolism, which led to such oddities as Sammy Davis, Jr’s 1974 album Satan Swings featuring Church of Satan founder Anton LeVey on background vocals. But in the days when Queen Victoria was young, people tended to be a bit more cautious about that sort of thing.

Lorna is played by Marilyn Joseph. Miss Joseph was at this time married to Christopher Pennock. Lorna’s ghost, or a simulacrum of it, will appear in #1145.

Episode 1141: Inheritance from the late Judah Zachery

Ever since we first saw his ghost scowling at us in July, when the show was set in the far-off future year 1995, Dark Shadows has been trying to build Gerard Stiles up as the next villain who will become a breakout star. Gerard’s ghost haunted the great house of Collinwood and masterminded its destruction in August and September 1970, when the show took place in a contemporary setting. For over six weeks now, we’ve been back on Gerard’s home territory, in the year 1840, where he is a living being. Today, they remember that they are supposed to make us care about him.

So far in 1840, Gerard has been a complete bust as a charming villain. James Storm’s natural appeal has been thwarted by Gerard’s limited range. So far, the only attitudes he has portrayed are Smug and Enraged, neither of them an inherently attractive state.

Nor have the people who like Gerard given us much reason to hope he will show a more appealing side. Lady novelist Flora Collins raves about him as “The Healer!,” but in their scenes together Gerard displayed only his customary self-satisfaction while Flora seemed determined to find something marvelous about him. Samantha Drew Collins, widow of Quentin Collins, was in love with Gerard and even married him. But Gerard was just as blandly smug in his scenes with her as he was in his scenes with Flora, and when it turned out Quentin wasn’t dead after all Samantha very quickly caught on that he never had any feelings for her, only for Quentin’s money. He dismissed her, and we haven’t seen her since. Quentin regards Gerard as a friend; he was amused to find that he and Samantha had had a wedding, and he is amused when he talks about Gerard’s presentation of himself as a seer. Quentin may enjoy Gerard’s company, but only to the extent that he doesn’t take him seriously.

Not only has Gerard not lived up to the “charming” half of “charming villain,” he barely qualifies as a villain at all. A villain is supposed to give the rest of the cast things to do. The protagonists get to be heroic, the ingenue gets to suffer nobly, etc, because of the villain’s evil deeds. But most of Gerard’s evil deeds have failed to attract anyone’s notice, let alone open up the story for participation by more characters. He now divides his time between two solitary pursuits, berating a severed head he keeps in his bedroom and fondling a jewel-encrusted golden mask he stole from the tomb where he found that head. Even the other residents of Flora’s house, a mansion known as Rose Cottage, don’t know about Gerard’s pastimes.

Teenager Carrie Stokes comes to Gerard’s room during his head-berating time. He is furious at the interruption. His anger stuns Carrie, who has been away for a few weeks and who has a crush on Gerard. Gerard eventually remembers to smile at Carrie, and sounds pleasant when he asks her to go away.

In 1970, Carrie’s ghost took possession of teenager Hallie Stokes. She was terribly afraid of Gerard’s ghost at that time, and Carrie/ Hallie was among those Gerard’s ghost murdered shortly before the show took us to 1840. So when regular viewers see Carrie brighten up at the sight of Gerard and try to flirt with him, it not only confirms that an adolescent girl might be attracted to him, but also takes us back to one of the moments when Gerard was impossibly repellent and revises it as a late stage in a story which has yet to be told. So that little scene is a step towards making Gerard interesting.

Gerard has figured out that the head is the focus of an evil spirit that is in the process of taking possession of him. Every member of the audience figured that out quite a while before he did. In fact, even after the head had told Gerard what it was doing in so many words, illustrating its explanation with vivid imagery in a dream visitation, Gerard still kept looking at the head and demanding further clarification. Gerard’s apparent cognitive limitations further undercut our hopes that he will be a dynamic presence in the plot. Interesting characters don’t have to be smart in an IQ sense, but they do have to know what they want, to observe what is going on around them, to absorb new information, and to use that information in their efforts to pursue their goals. Until today, Gerard has not shown the ability to do any of those things.

Gerard finally does something with a definable purpose when he takes the head, still in its glass case, to the top of the cliff on Widow’s Hill and throws it to the rocks below.

Gerard flings the head over Widows’ Hill. Screenshot by Dark Shadows Before I Die.

Carrie emerges from the darkness the moment after Gerard flings the head into the abyss. He demands to know what she saw and why she is there. She says she saw nothing, and that she followed him to see if he was meeting a girl. He calms down and makes another attempt to be charming. She says that he seems to be himself again. He is happy with this idea.

Gerard takes Carrie back to Rose Cottage. Her governess, Daphne Harridge, is waiting for her there. Daphne says that she will take Carrie back home to the great house on the estate of Collinwood. But then it turns out that Samantha has sent her son Tad, Daphne’s other charge, to stay with Flora at Rose Cottage and that there is no reason Carrie should not stay there as well. Gerard sends Carrie out of the room to say goodnight to Flora.

Gerard takes this as an opportunity to pressure Daphne to go out with him on a date. Daphne has only just met Carrie and may not know about her feelings for Gerard. Nonetheless, she is uncomfortable with the idea of going out with him, partly because Samantha’s sister Roxanne just died, partly because of Gerard’s aggressive manner, and partly because Flora’s son Desmond already forced her to spend some hours socializing with him in the afternoon. She keeps refusing, and he keeps informing her that he will call for her at Collinwood in an hour.

After a hostile interlude with Desmond, Gerard spends some quality time fondling the mask. He then gets very sleepy. He yells down the hall at Carrie, saying he is about to take a nap and asking her to wake him in half an hour. She yells back that she will be glad to. As is customary for men in Collinsport, he lies down on the bed fully clothed, boots and all. He dreams that Carrie wakes him, saying that a pleasant man has come to see him. He opens the door to find a man he has never seen holding the glass case that he had thrown off the cliff. He awakens, and the same scene plays out.

The man is unknown to Gerard, but familiar to longtime viewers. He is Humbert Allen Astredo. In 1968, Astredo played the suave Nicholas Blair, who was introduced as a warlock of unfathomably vast powers. Astredo’s talents as an actor were so considerable that he held our attention for weeks and weeks, keeping us waiting to see what terrible plan Nicholas was pursuing. When it finally became clear that Nicholas was flying blind and that whatever he might come up with to do was going to fail almost immediately, the disappointment was so bitter that he had to be incinerated and dragged back to Hell in front of us. Apparently even that wasn’t sufficient punishment for having disappointed us so thoroughly. When another storyline collapsed early in 1970, they brought Nicholas back for a couple of weeks, just so that they could kill him off again.

In between his two tours of duty as Nicholas, Astredo appeared in the long segment of Dark Shadows set in 1897 as lawyer/ Satanist Evan Hanley. Evan was both a commentary on Nicholas and a great improvement on him. He aspired to become what Nicholas was introduced as already being. That gave him a set of goals and kept us in suspense as to how close he would come to achieving them. When he fell short of his objectives, it was interesting to see what would happen to him and how he would react to it.

We can’t tell who Astredo is today. He might be a third run-through of Nicholas. If so, we can expect that he will strut and preen and tell Gerard that he cannot escape what is in store for him. When Gerard’s personality is erased and James Storm starts playing the evil spirit of the head, Nicholas will become his helpless stooge and wind up in yet another damnation scene. That sounds pretty dismal. But if this is another human aspiring to become a warlock, perhaps he will recapture the spark that Astredo cultivated as Evan. If that happens, Gerard or whatever takes Gerard’s place just might have an associate in whose company he can finally shine brightly enough to become what we had hoped he would be.

Episode 1140: Merely an extension of life

The dramatic date is 1840. This is quite an ambitious half-hour, featuring both a dream sequence and a flashback.

The head of warlock Judah Zachery and the rest of his body maintained separate residences from the time Judah was put to death in 1692 until the other day. Mad scientist Julia Hoffman and Cockney showgirl/ psychic Leticia Faye fell under Judah’s power and reattached the head to the body. Seagoing con man Gerard Stiles found his way to the vault where the reconstituted Judah was resting after this procedure. Judah attacked Gerard who in the course of escaping from him started a fire that destroyed the body. Now the head is back in its glass case, and Gerard is keeping it in his room. He is falling under Judah’s power, and has a dream today in which he sees his own head in the case while Judah stands outside. He hears Judah’s voice saying that he will take Gerard’s body for his own, and that Gerard will cease to exist. Regular viewers have likely seen this coming for some time, and it is a relief that Gerard is finally catching on.

Gerard’s vision of Judah looking at his head in the case. Screenshot by Dark Shadows Before I Die.

Gerard is in the drawing room of the great house of Collinwood when wicked witch Angelique enters. They have not previously met. He introduces himself as Gerard Stiles. Before she can identify herself, he tells her that she once answered to the name Miranda. She is startled by this. He cannot explain why he said it. He says that he has never known anyone named Miranda. He excuses himself.

Angelique thinks back to the last time she was known as Miranda, which was in 1692. She was the key witness at Judah’s trial. We see Amadeus Collins browbeat Angelique with threats that she will be executed if she does not testify and with promises that she will be given safe passage out of the country if she does. She testifies, over Judah’s loud objections. Judah is convicted.

Amadeus pressures Miranda to testify. Screenshot by Dark Shadows Before I Die.

In his post about the episode on his great blog Dark Shadows Every Day, Danny Horn objects that the flashback represents a bad retcon. He describes it as “a perplexing revelation that basically eviscerates everything that we thought that we knew, and doesn’t replace it with anything.” I’d say it’s even worse. We first met Angelique late in 1967, when the show was set in 1795. At that time, we heard from people who knew her and her family when she was a little girl fifteen or twenty years before. We also saw that, while she had an awe-inspiring gift for black magic, she seemed to be a novice at it. She was continually surprising herself with the disastrous results of her spells. That made it possible for us to care about her later, when she became a more sympathetic character and an ally of the protagonists. If we suppose that she was already so skilled at witchcraft in 1692 that she could still be alive and not look a day older in 1795, that all falls apart.

The cosmology the show has developed with its journeys through time and the multiverse might leave a couple of options open to explain how Angelique could have been around in 1692, but what we see today forecloses those options. Perhaps she traveled back in time sometime between the 1790s and 1840. But as Danny points out, Lara Parker’s performance in the flashback eliminates that possibility. She plays “Miranda” as a true innocent, helpless between Judah and the court, without so much as a flicker in her eye suggesting that she might have some secrets of her own that she is keeping from Amadeus Collins.

We’ve seen “astral twins,” characters set in different periods who are played by the same actor and are in some sense the same person. Occasionally a sorcerer can cause the personality of one of these twins to invade the consciousness of the other. Angelique did this when a spell of hers caused Roger Collins to be intermittently possessed by his eighteenth century ancestor Joshua Collins in starting in #470. In #1107, a ghost which appeared to be Gerard, but which we now suppose to be Judah, caused the Quentin Collins who was born in 1870 to channel his great-uncle Quentin, who was born in 1810. But without the magical interventions, neither Roger nor Quentin knew much about his twin. Quentin had never even heard of his great uncle until he found his name in some old papers a few days before Gerard/ Judah mind-melded them. Angelique looks back on Miranda’s life as an earlier phase of her own, so regular viewers can exclude the “astral twin” explanation.

As Danny points out, the Miranda story is just an attempt to graft Judah onto the early history of the Collins family so that he seems dramatically satisfying as a major threat to them. They use Angelique because she seems to be the only major character whom they can patch back into a seventeenth century story. But since they get her there in a way that kicks load-bearing elements out of the continuity, it winds up making Judah seem even more like a random visitor.

In his previous appearances as Judah, even in the episodes where Judah was in one piece, Michael McGuire was credited as “The Head.” Today, he is finally credited as “Judah Zachery.” But he shares the part with Keene Curtis. It is Curtis’ voice Gerard hears in his dream and Curtis who appears in the trial sequence as Judah wearing a black mask and objecting to Miranda’s testimony. They cut away from the speaking Judah and back to Michael McGuire in a matching costume. McGuire is built quite differently than Curtis, so the cut is jarring. McGuire pulls the mask off and shows the face we have come to think of as Judah’s.

It mystifies me that a show with such a tight budget as Dark Shadows chose to pay two actors for playing one part. McGuire had a fine actorly voice and had already appeared in several plays in New York, including the Broadway runs of The Passion of Josef D. and Child’s Play, and in the feature films Coming Apart and Where’s Poppa? (also known as Going Ape.) Curtis had an impressive face and was at this time acting in his 25th Broadway show. So either of them would have been well-qualified to play a whole part.

I first became aware of Michael McGuire in 1982, when he appeared in the pilot episode of Cheers as Professor Sumner Sloane, who dumps his date Diane Chambers and strands her at the bar. He reprised that role in two subsequent episodes of the show. None of McGuire’s three episodes of Cheers featured bar owner Sam Malone’s nemesis, John Allen Hill, who was played in his fifteen episodes by Keene Curtis. So when the characters talk about leaving Collinsport for Boston, we might wonder if they are looking to have a drink someplace where everybody knows their names.