Episode 1147: We were dead

Quentin Collins hired Daphne Harridge, a woman he had never before met, as governess to his son Tad and to permanent houseguest Carrie Stokes. At just about the time this person he did not know gained access to his house, notes addressed to him started showing up from the late Joanna Mills, with whom he had an affair some time before her death. Today Quentin sets a trap to find who is leaving the notes. Daphne walks in with a note in her hand. He is thunderstruck, since he had not suspected her.

Daphne shows Quentin that the note is addressed to someone else, and he assumes she must be innocent. The moment she leaves the room, he finds that there is now a note on the table next to where Daphne was standing while he was looking at the other note. It would seem obvious that Daphne left that note while he wasn’t looking, but then it has been obvious from the beginning that Daphne was probably behind the notes. So it is no surprise Quentin doesn’t make the connection. By the end of the episode he is beaten over the head with some information that reveals Daphne is Joanna’s sister, which the audience figured out several days ago. When he confronts her with this fact, we wonder if she will be able to make him let go of it as easily as she convinced him she wasn’t leaving the notes.

Daphne doesn’t seem to be significantly brighter than Quentin. She has come to Collinwood intending to murder Quentin. She decides today that before she does that, he will fall in love with her. She gets him to give her a couple of passionate kisses. After that, she is left thinking to herself that she does not share his incipient feelings for her, that her behavior is just part of her plan. If so, her plan is as hopelessly dumb as is Quentin’s failure to put one and one together. Nor is there any sign of intelligence in the dialogue today. It takes a lot to make us dread the sight of actors as appealing as David Selby and Kate Jackson, but this episode manages it.

Daphne and Quentin. Screenshot by Dark Shadows Before I Die.

There is also a scene in which Quentin’s wife Samantha barges in on Daphne’s tutorial with her charges. Carrie and Tad are yelling at each other at the moment Samantha enters. She scolds Daphne for failing to discipline them. By the end of the scene, she is forbidding her to discipline them. Virginia Vestoff is usually as irresistible in her way as Mr Selby and Miss Jackson are in theirs; in this dismal scene, they succeed in making Samantha entirely resistible.

This is the first time we have seen Tad as a living being, and the first time we have seen David Henesy since #1109. Tad is in a foul mood. He doesn’t like anyone he meets. He isn’t clever about expressing his hostility, but simply tries to irritate everyone. He taunts Carrie, defies Daphne, and ignores Samantha. Mr Henesy’s characters have often been the fulcra on which major developments in the story of Dark Shadows have turned. So the very first thing we learned about the menace to the Collins family lurking at the heart of the current segment is that in 1970, Tad’s ghost will take possession of his Doppelgänger, strange and troubled boy David Collins, resulting in David’s death. The journey back in time to 1840 is, therefore, largely an attempt to redeem Tad and rescue David. That might be a significantly more compelling if Tad weren’t such an annoying little shit.

Carrie has received a gift, a crystal ball. The giver was ostensibly seagoing con man Gerard Stiles, a friend of Quentin and sometime lover of Samantha, but in fact Gerard no longer exists. His body is occupied by warlock Judah Zachery, an implacable foe of all the Collinses. We first saw this prop in #48, when it was a gift to David from Burke Devlin. Burke was a former friend of David’s father Roger, sometime lover of his mother Laura, and an implacable foe of all the Collinses.

Carrie looks in the crystal ball. Kathleen Cody is the one member of the cast who is pleasant to watch today, and she does what she can with a speech describing the dark and indefinite forms visible in the crystal changing their shape. But since the camera gives us an unobstructed view of the perfectly transparent glass orb throughout the whole of this speech, the visuals undercut her. When she claims to see herself and Tad lying dead on the floor of the very room in which they now sit, she says that “We look like we did now!,” suggesting that they have little time left, certainly too little for Daphne to teach them correct grammar. A premonition of Carrie and Tad’s deaths harks back to a drum the show beat so heavily in the lead-up to the jump from 1970 to 1840 that regular viewers knew exactly what Carrie would see as soon as she unpacked the crystal ball, and the whole scene is too straightforward to create a dramatically satisfying sense of inevitability. It’s just the same old thing one more time.

Nothing works in this one. It moves incredibly slowly. At the halfway mark, I was astounded the credits didn’t start rolling. It felt like we’d been watching for at least half an hour, and the second half crept by if anything more slowly.

Leave a Reply