Episode 1150: The sisterhood of the living dead

Day is breaking, and vampire Roxanne Drew has returned to her tomb. Roxanne finds her brother Randall standing in front of her coffin, holding a cross. Randall asks Roxanne who made her a vampire. She refuses to answer. In the last moments before she disintegrates in the morning light, she calls out the name “Barnabas.”

A certain Barnabas Collins told Randall that Roxanne was a vampire. Barnabas later took Roxanne’s victim Lamar Trask away from the tomb so that he could not stop Randall from putting his sister to rest. Randall goes to Barnabas’ home, the Old House on the estate of Collinwood. He does not find him, but does hear Lamar shouting in the basement. Barnabas locked Lamar up there and is nowhere to be found. Randall goes to the great house on the estate to find a key to release Lamar.

At the great house, Randall finds two people at home. One is Quentin Collins, heir to the Collins fortune and acting head of the family. The other is a woman he knows as Julia Collins, sister of Barnabas. Julia had been Roxanne’s first victim. Randall notes that Julia is fully recovered from the grievous wounds Roxanne had inflicted on her, wounds which had her at death’s door just a few hours previously. He tells Julia and Quentin the whole story. They have a couple of drinks and agree to keep Roxanne’s fate secret. Randall has probably been at the house for about an hour when Julia gets around to suggesting they go to the Old House and let Lamar out. Lamar is, as they say, a lot. No one is in all that much of a hurry to have him back out where he might at any time show up in your house and yell at you.

Once freed, Lamar starts jabbering that he heard the sound of chains rattling behind a brick wall in the basement. Julia identifies the wall as part of the foundations of the house, which is certainly what it looks like. Even a well-adjusted person might lose control of himself after going through what Lamar has been through in the last several hours, and there can’t be many people who know Lamar and would call him “well-adjusted.”

Nonetheless, Randall takes Lamar seriously, at least for a little while. He will not join in Lamar’s demand that the wall be torn down, but he does have questions for Barnabas. How did he come to know so much about vampires, and where is he now? He and Lamar leave together, and Julia frets that she has not allayed Randall’s suspicions.

Julia can’t believe she has to work this hard to throw two dopes like Lamar and Randall off the track. Screenshot by Dark Shadows Before I Die.

Julia is not, in fact, Barnabas’ sister. She is a medical doctor and mad scientist who first became aware of Barnabas in the summer of 1967, when an escaped victim of his was a hospitalized patient of hers. Doubly qualified as a blood specialist and a psychiatrist, Julia approached Barnabas with a proposition. She was working on an experimental treatment to cure vampirism. If he would agree to serve as a test subject, she would protect his secret. He accepted that deal, and by the summer of 1968 he and Julia had become best friends.

Since then, Julia and Barnabas have had many adventures together. Those have involved traveling backward in time to the nineteenth century, forward in time to the far-off future year 1995, and sideways in time to an alternate universe. When Julia traveled back in time from 1970 to the current year, 1840, she told the members of the Collins family she found living on the estate of Collinwood that she was their distant cousin and that she was expecting that her brother Barnabas would soon arrive from England. She and Barnabas have for all practical purposes been functioning as a close-knit pair of siblings for some time, so this imposture is logical enough.

Julia and Barnabas were in the alternate universe in #1039. This was when we first saw a version of Roxanne. Donna Wandrey’s short red hair, pale skin, and strong chin gave her a strong enough resemblance to Grayson Hall that we wondered if Roxanne would turn out to be the daughter of Julia’s counterpart in that universe of inverted mirror images. They didn’t develop that idea. Pairing the story of dutiful brother Randall destroying vampire Roxanne with that of virtual sister Julia protecting vampire Barnabas creates another inverted mirror image. The show may not have built a story around Miss Wandrey’s resemblance to Hall, but that resemblance does serve as a visual marker underlining the contrast between the two sets of siblings.

Sisterhood comes up in today’s B story as well. Governess Daphne Harridge is the sister of Joanna Mills, who was once the mistress of Quentin Collins. Daphne and Joanna were very close, and Quentin did love Joanna after his fashion. So Daphne and Quentin hold a séance today to contact Joanna’s spirit. We’ve heard enough about Joanna that it is plausible her ghost might show up, and a mysterious figure does appear at the climax of the séance.

It’s hard to get excited about the idea of bringing a ghost onto the show right now. So few characters seem even to like each other that it is hard to come up with credible motivations for anyone to do anything except look for a place to be alone. And there are are plenty of dynamic supernatural villains around. So a wispy presence whose connection to the rest of the cast of characters cannot quite be defined would seem to be the very last thing they need. Still, Daphne is played by the irresistible Kate Jackson, so we might enjoy getting to know her better as we see her interact with the sister who means so much to her.

They do a deep dive into the show’s iconography to make it seem that Joanna’s ghost might turn out to matter. The mysterious figure is a hooded form wearing a gown in the doorway of the drawing room of the great house at Collinwood. This is a recreation of a shot from #170, which was also recreated in #860. In #170, the hooded figure was Laura Murdoch Collins, an undead fire witch whose story absorbed most of the open narrative threads on the show and committed Dark Shadows to being a supernatural thriller. In #860, it turned out to be Judith Collins, whose arrival was nothing more than a bridge between the closing cliffhanger of that episode and the first act of the next.

It’s hard to see how Joanna’s ghost could follow Laura’s lead and take over the show, and equally hard to see how she could serve so minor a function as Judith’s in #861. So perhaps it will turn out to be someone else.

The two female characters capable of taking control of the plot as Laura once did are Julia and wicked witch Angelique. If the hooded figure turns out to be one of them, the resonance with Laura in #170 might be a promise that her part will be decisive when the 1840 segment is resolved. If it is another female character, the resonance with #860 and #861 may be a sign that Dark Shadows’ visual vocabulary has run very dry and it is time for the audience to find something else to do at 4 PM on weekdays. If it is a male character in drag, the show will have taken a turn to self-parody which would seem to have been a bit more in keeping with the campy Zeitgeist of the mid-1960s than with the more earnest attitude typical of 1970. Still, if they’re looking for a change in tone, it might have been worth a try.

The title of this post is taken from Wallace Stevens’ “To the One of Fictive Music“:

Sister and mother and diviner love,
And of the sisterhood of the living dead
Most near, most clear, and of the clearest bloom,
And of the fragrant mothers the most dear
And queen, and of diviner love the day
And flame and summer and sweet fire, no thread
Of cloudy silver sprinkles in your gown
Its venom of renown, and on your head
No crown is simpler than the simple hair.

Now, of the music summoned by the birth
That separates us from the wind and sea,
Yet leaves us in them, until earth becomes,
By being so much of the things we are,
Gross effigy and simulacrum, none
Gives motion to perfection more serene
Than yours, out of our own imperfections wrought,
Most rare, or ever of more kindred air
In the laborious weaving that you wear.

For so retentive of themselves are men
That music is intensest which proclaims
The near, the clear, and vaunts the clearest bloom,
And of all the vigils musing the obscure,
That apprehends the most which sees and names,
As in your name, an image that is sure,
Among the arrant spices of the sun,
O bough and bush and scented vine, in whom
We give ourselves our likest issuance.

Yet not too like, yet not so like to be
Too near, too clear, saving a little to endow
Our feigning with the strange unlike, whence springs
The difference that heavenly pity brings.
For this, musician, in your girdle fixed
Bear other perfumes. On your pale head wear
A band entwining, set with fatal stones.
Unreal, give back to us what once you gave:
The imagination that we spurned and crave.

Wallace Stevens, “To the One of Fictive Music,” as published in his collection Harmonium (Knopf, 1923)

I don’t suppose I need to add anything to explain my choice of “The sisterhood of the living dead” as a title. But I do think the whole poem speaks to today’s episode. Neither Gene Lindsey nor Miss Wandrey gets much love from Dark Shadows bloggers, but they both do fine work today. Randall and Roxanne are very raw and basic. They are just themselves when they confront each other in the tomb. She is not the legendary terror from beyond the grave, he is not the heroic defender of the natural order of things. They are simply two people who grew up together, who care about each other, and who are used to knowing everything about each other. She is impelled to attack him, and he keeps her away with that “fatal stone,” the cross. Her last energies are spent on one final effort to keep a secret from him. The bizarre circumstances are stripped away, the plain human feeling remains. “[N]o thread/ of cloudy silver sprinkles in your gown/ a venom of renown.”

A vampire is a metaphor for extreme selfishness, and Julia has surrendered everything in her life to become an appendix to Barnabas’ narcissism. Because she serves him so tirelessly and reflects him back to himself as mirrors can no longer do, he cannot be at ease when he is separated from her. “For so retentive of themselves are men/ That music is intensest which proclaims/ The near, the clear, and vaunts the clearest bloom/…in whom/ We give ourselves our likest issuance.” Julia has reinvented herself as the likest issuance for which even Barnabas could hope.

Randall sees what his beloved sister has become, and knows what he himself would want in her place. He steels himself to relieve her of her cruelly extended existence. “Yet not too like, yet not so like to be/ Too near, too clear, saving a little to endow/ Our feigning with the strange unlike, whence springs/ The difference that heavenly pity brings.”

Too near, too clear. All relationships in Soap Opera Land serve as a basis for deception, either beginning when one party deceives another, deepening when the parties join together to deceive someone else, or shattering when deceptions are exposed. Roxanne is too near to Randall, too clear to his understanding, for the two of them to be on screen together very long.

“Unreal, give back to us what once you gave:/ The imagination that we spurned and crave.” We have seen other vampires destroyed, in some cases by wooden stakes through their hearts. That violent, bloody act makes the vampire seem like a gruesome physical reality, its destruction an onerous labor. But when they melt away in the sunlight, they are presented as bad dreams that can’t hurt us once we are awake. Choosing that method, they present Roxanne as “Unreal.” Seeing Randall with Roxanne, we picture them as children playing together, building their imaginations together. When Randall first joined the cast of characters, he was one of the “Surely There Must Be a Logical Explanation!” people. Only when he saw the evidence of what had happened to Roxanne could he consider the possibility of supernatural events. He had spurned that side of imagination which is most essential to surviving in a world like that of Dark Shadows. Now he has put that same side of it to work to satisfy his craving for answers to questions that he can only doom himself by asking.

Episode 1148: A time-honored way to steal your soul

In #1109, mad scientist Julia Hoffman came unstuck in time and found herself in the year 1840. In #1117, her best friend, vampire Barnabas Collins, followed her there.

Now, Julia is trapped in a deserted lighthouse, dying from wounds inflicted on her by a vampire named Roxanne whom wicked witch Angelique controls. Angelique’s henchman Laszlo comes to taunt Julia about her impending death and rising as a vampire. He notices that she is wearing a fine ring, which he promptly steals.

Laszlo goes to the Old House on the grounds of the estate of Collinwood. Barnabas and Angelique are both based in that house. Angelique and Barnabas were once married, and she is forcing him to pretend they still are. Laszlo is looking for Angelique, but Barnabas is the one at home. Laszlo tries to lie his way out of the awkward situation, but when Barnabas sees Julia’s ring on his finger he grabs him by the throat and demands to know where she is. We end with Barnabas letting himself into Julia’s prison and seeing that she appears already to be dead.

Barnabas recognizes Julia’s ring. Screenshot by Dark Shadows Before I Die.

Also in this episode, Quentin Collins has figured out that governess Daphne Harridge is actually the sister of the late Joanna Mills, with whom he had an affair some time before her death. Daphne admits to being Joanna’s sister, and says that she came to the great house at Collinwood with the intention of killing him. She blames him for Joanna’s death. He denies responsibility for this, and she is convinced.

When Daphne first came to Collinwood, someone started leaving notes for Quentin, apparently from Joanna. We actually saw Daphne leave the first of these notes in #1122, and just yesterday Quentin found another such note on the table next to a spot where Daphne had been standing while he wasn’t looking at her. Daphne continues to deny that she is responsible for the notes, and he decides that someone else must be leaving them. He names Joanna’s ghost as a suspect. Another note appears in the drawing room today while Quentin and Daphne are alone there. This one is addressed to Daphne, and she reacts with distress when Quentin reads it to her. The audience knows that the show is mainly about the supernatural, so we may not regard Quentin as a complete idiot. But it still seems pretty obvious that Daphne is leaving the notes.

Episode 1147: We were dead

Quentin Collins hired Daphne Harridge, a woman he had never before met, as governess to his son Tad and to permanent houseguest Carrie Stokes. At just about the time this person he did not know gained access to his house, notes addressed to him started showing up from the late Joanna Mills, with whom he had an affair some time before her death. Today Quentin sets a trap to find who is leaving the notes. Daphne walks in with a note in her hand. He is thunderstruck, since he had not suspected her.

Daphne shows Quentin that the note is addressed to someone else, and he assumes she must be innocent. The moment she leaves the room, he finds that there is now a note on the table next to where Daphne was standing while he was looking at the other note. It would seem obvious that Daphne left that note while he wasn’t looking, but then it has been obvious from the beginning that Daphne was probably behind the notes. So it is no surprise Quentin doesn’t make the connection. By the end of the episode he is beaten over the head with some information that reveals Daphne is Joanna’s sister, which the audience figured out several days ago. When he confronts her with this fact, we wonder if she will be able to make him let go of it as easily as she convinced him she wasn’t leaving the notes.

Daphne doesn’t seem to be significantly brighter than Quentin. She has come to Collinwood intending to murder Quentin. She decides today that before she does that, he will fall in love with her. She gets him to give her a couple of passionate kisses. After that, she is left thinking to herself that she does not share his incipient feelings for her, that her behavior is just part of her plan. If so, her plan is as hopelessly dumb as is Quentin’s failure to put one and one together. Nor is there any sign of intelligence in the dialogue today. It takes a lot to make us dread the sight of actors as appealing as David Selby and Kate Jackson, but this episode manages it.

Daphne and Quentin. Screenshot by Dark Shadows Before I Die.

There is also a scene in which Quentin’s wife Samantha barges in on Daphne’s tutorial with her charges. Carrie and Tad are yelling at each other at the moment Samantha enters. She scolds Daphne for failing to discipline them. By the end of the scene, she is forbidding her to discipline them. Virginia Vestoff is usually as irresistible in her way as Mr Selby and Miss Jackson are in theirs; in this dismal scene, they succeed in making Samantha entirely resistible.

This is the first time we have seen Tad as a living being, and the first time we have seen David Henesy since #1109. Tad is in a foul mood. He doesn’t like anyone he meets. He isn’t clever about expressing his hostility, but simply tries to irritate everyone. He taunts Carrie, defies Daphne, and ignores Samantha. Mr Henesy’s characters have often been the fulcra on which major developments in the story of Dark Shadows have turned. So the very first thing we learned about the menace to the Collins family lurking at the heart of the current segment is that in 1970, Tad’s ghost will take possession of his Doppelgänger, strange and troubled boy David Collins, resulting in David’s death. The journey back in time to 1840 is, therefore, largely an attempt to redeem Tad and rescue David. That might be a significantly more compelling if Tad weren’t such an annoying little shit.

Carrie has received a gift, a crystal ball. The giver was ostensibly seagoing con man Gerard Stiles, a friend of Quentin and sometime lover of Samantha, but in fact Gerard no longer exists. His body is occupied by warlock Judah Zachery, an implacable foe of all the Collinses. We first saw this prop in #48, when it was a gift to David from Burke Devlin. Burke was a former friend of David’s father Roger, sometime lover of his mother Laura, and an implacable foe of all the Collinses.

Carrie looks in the crystal ball. Kathleen Cody is the one member of the cast who is pleasant to watch today, and she does what she can with a speech describing the dark and indefinite forms visible in the crystal changing their shape. But since the camera gives us an unobstructed view of the perfectly transparent glass orb throughout the whole of this speech, the visuals undercut her. When she claims to see herself and Tad lying dead on the floor of the very room in which they now sit, she says that “We look like we did now!,” suggesting that they have little time left, certainly too little for Daphne to teach them correct grammar. A premonition of Carrie and Tad’s deaths harks back to a drum the show beat so heavily in the lead-up to the jump from 1970 to 1840 that regular viewers knew exactly what Carrie would see as soon as she unpacked the crystal ball, and the whole scene is too straightforward to create a dramatically satisfying sense of inevitability. It’s just the same old thing one more time.

Nothing works in this one. It moves incredibly slowly. At the halfway mark, I was astounded the credits didn’t start rolling. It felt like we’d been watching for at least half an hour, and the second half crept by if anything more slowly.

Episode 1146: D is for Daphne. D is also for the Devil.

Warlock Judah Zachery has evicted seagoing con man Gerard Stiles from his body and taken it for himself. None of Gerard’s acquaintances has noticed the difference.

Gerard was angling for the attentions of governess Daphne Harridge, a project Judah is continuing. Today he sees Daphne in the drawing room of the great house of Collinwood. He repels her with his insistence that she will want him. At one point, the expression on his face so terrifies her that she says she cannot imagine ever forgetting it.

Judah’s powers include the ability to send dreams to people. Daphne has a dream in which she is desperately attracted to “Gerard,” and after she awakens she goes back to the drawing room and hangs out with Judah for a little while.

Unknown to Judah, Daphne is not the wholesome innocent she seems to be. She has come to Collinwood vowing to murder Quentin Collins, father of her charge Tad. Shortly after Daphne’s arrival, Quentin started getting notes apparently from Joanna Mills, a woman with whom he had an affair a few years ago. Since Joanna has been dead since last November, this is rather puzzling. The other day, one of these notes instructed Quentin to meet Joanna at a secret trysting place of theirs in the woods. When he got there, he saw Daphne from behind. Her slender figure and long black hair led him to think she was Joanna until she turned around and he saw her face. So we know that Daphne looks very much like Joanna. Before he was replaced by Judah, Gerard had learned that “Daphne Harridge” was likely an alias. It seems that she is Joanna’s sister, that she blames Quentin for Joanna’s death, that this is her motive for wanting to kill Quentin, and that the notes are part of her murder plan. At the end of today’s episode, Quentin catches Daphne with a note.

Daphne caught red-handed. Screenshot by Dark Shadows Before I Die.

There are some memorable moments today. We open in the basement of Collinwood, where Judah has given a terrible shock to Quentin’s father Daniel. As a result, Daniel is having a cardiac episode. Daniel’s second son, Gabriel Collins, enters and asks what is going on. Judah orders him to hurry upstairs and fetch a doctor. Gabriel uses a wheelchair, and the year is 1840. So it is hard to imagine how he got into the basement by himself without attracting attention, and even harder to imagine how he could hurry up a flight of stairs. Gabriel is always turning up on different floors of the house, which the show never explains. But this is an especially laughable example.

Daphne walks in on Quentin when he is drunk. He starts telling her how sad everyone in his family is. When he gets around to mentioning that his father killed his mother, he notices her reaction of shock. He then says mildly that it is a “well-known secret.” Some websites list this as a blooper, but I’m sure it was scripted. Quentin’s dialogue includes many such ironic turns of phrase, and returning viewers will remember that when we saw Daniel in #1110 he introduced himself by raving to the first stranger who came along that he had murdered his wife. The Collinses may be rich enough to keep law enforcement from bringing their patriarch to justice, but their wealth and power also make them the cynosure of everyone in the village of Collinsport. There can’t be many people there who do not know the whole story of Daniel’s killing of Harriet.

When Judah is preparing to cast his spell on Daphne, he intones “D is for Daphne. D is also for the Devil.” James Storm’s style of acting is somewhat like choral singing, in that he finds a single pitch and holds to it throughout each line he delivers. When he is paired with a strong scene partner like Louis Edmonds or Virginia Vestoff or Christopher Pennock, this mode of enunciation can be effective. But it tends to monotony when he has to give a soliloquy, and starting from a line like “D is for Daphne” this speech sounds like a bad parody of Sesame Street. “This episode is brought to you by the number 666!”

Terry Crawford is in a few scenes as Gabriel’s odious wife Edith. Miss Crawford is an extremely nice person, and can do a good job playing a character who is not in any way complex. The moment she has to indicate mixed emotions or show that her character is concealing her true feelings, she goes splat. Her first and last scenes are with Gabriel, and revolve around the possibility that Daniel will change his will in Gabriel’s favor. Edith has nothing to hide from Gabriel, and so Miss Crawford has no trouble in the first scene making it clear that Edith is very greedy and in the last scene making it clear that she regards Gabriel’s disability with contempt. In between, Edith has a scene with Judah, whom she believes to be Gerard. She is at once attracted to “Gerard” and frustrated with him, a combination that defeats Miss Crawford so thoroughly her lines come out as if she were reading each word off a separate fortune cookie slip.

I sometimes wonder if Edith might have been a more fruitful part of the story had she been played by a more accomplished actress. After all, regular viewers know that it is her descendants who will ultimately inherit the Collins fortune, and a much older version of the character made a big impression in March 1969, when the show was set in 1897.

In the 1897 segment, the nonagenarian Edith was played with great verve by Isabella Hoopes. Lisa Blake Richards looked a little bit like a young version of Hoopes, certainly far more than Miss Crawford ever did. Miss Richards played two parts on the show, both women named Sabrina, the first of whom gave her almost nothing to work with, the second of whom was just getting interesting when her storyline came to an abrupt conclusion.

In 1966, Miss Richards made her television debut on WGBH, the educational station in Boston. They broadcast a production of Gertrude Stein’s play “Yes is for a Very Young Man.” The Harvard Crimson‘s 1965 review of the play as performed by the same company had singled Miss Richards out as one of the best in a fine cast that struggled to elevate a bad play, writing that “Lisa Richards as [the protagonist’s] wife does an outstanding job with a whining, pathetic character.” In Miss Crawford’s hands, Edith is also a whining, pathetic character. In the 1897 segment, lady’s maid Beth Chavez was originally supposed to be complex and multilayered. When the writers saw that Miss Crawford couldn’t handle that, they retooled Beth as someone who spoke blunt truths and couldn’t be bothered with nonsense. Perhaps if Miss Richards had taken the part of Edith her abilities might have inspired the writers to come up with something closer to what the audience had a right to expect from such an important figure in the Collins family’s history.

Episode 1141: Inheritance from the late Judah Zachery

Ever since we first saw his ghost scowling at us in July, when the show was set in the far-off future year 1995, Dark Shadows has been trying to build Gerard Stiles up as the next villain who will become a breakout star. Gerard’s ghost haunted the great house of Collinwood and masterminded its destruction in August and September 1970, when the show took place in a contemporary setting. For over six weeks now, we’ve been back on Gerard’s home territory, in the year 1840, where he is a living being. Today, they remember that they are supposed to make us care about him.

So far in 1840, Gerard has been a complete bust as a charming villain. James Storm’s natural appeal has been thwarted by Gerard’s limited range. So far, the only attitudes he has portrayed are Smug and Enraged, neither of them an inherently attractive state.

Nor have the people who like Gerard given us much reason to hope he will show a more appealing side. Lady novelist Flora Collins raves about him as “The Healer!,” but in their scenes together Gerard displayed only his customary self-satisfaction while Flora seemed determined to find something marvelous about him. Samantha Drew Collins, widow of Quentin Collins, was in love with Gerard and even married him. But Gerard was just as blandly smug in his scenes with her as he was in his scenes with Flora, and when it turned out Quentin wasn’t dead after all Samantha very quickly caught on that he never had any feelings for her, only for Quentin’s money. He dismissed her, and we haven’t seen her since. Quentin regards Gerard as a friend; he was amused to find that he and Samantha had had a wedding, and he is amused when he talks about Gerard’s presentation of himself as a seer. Quentin may enjoy Gerard’s company, but only to the extent that he doesn’t take him seriously.

Not only has Gerard not lived up to the “charming” half of “charming villain,” he barely qualifies as a villain at all. A villain is supposed to give the rest of the cast things to do. The protagonists get to be heroic, the ingenue gets to suffer nobly, etc, because of the villain’s evil deeds. But most of Gerard’s evil deeds have failed to attract anyone’s notice, let alone open up the story for participation by more characters. He now divides his time between two solitary pursuits, berating a severed head he keeps in his bedroom and fondling a jewel-encrusted golden mask he stole from the tomb where he found that head. Even the other residents of Flora’s house, a mansion known as Rose Cottage, don’t know about Gerard’s pastimes.

Teenager Carrie Stokes comes to Gerard’s room during his head-berating time. He is furious at the interruption. His anger stuns Carrie, who has been away for a few weeks and who has a crush on Gerard. Gerard eventually remembers to smile at Carrie, and sounds pleasant when he asks her to go away.

In 1970, Carrie’s ghost took possession of teenager Hallie Stokes. She was terribly afraid of Gerard’s ghost at that time, and Carrie/ Hallie was among those Gerard’s ghost murdered shortly before the show took us to 1840. So when regular viewers see Carrie brighten up at the sight of Gerard and try to flirt with him, it not only confirms that an adolescent girl might be attracted to him, but also takes us back to one of the moments when Gerard was impossibly repellent and revises it as a late stage in a story which has yet to be told. So that little scene is a step towards making Gerard interesting.

Gerard has figured out that the head is the focus of an evil spirit that is in the process of taking possession of him. Every member of the audience figured that out quite a while before he did. In fact, even after the head had told Gerard what it was doing in so many words, illustrating its explanation with vivid imagery in a dream visitation, Gerard still kept looking at the head and demanding further clarification. Gerard’s apparent cognitive limitations further undercut our hopes that he will be a dynamic presence in the plot. Interesting characters don’t have to be smart in an IQ sense, but they do have to know what they want, to observe what is going on around them, to absorb new information, and to use that information in their efforts to pursue their goals. Until today, Gerard has not shown the ability to do any of those things.

Gerard finally does something with a definable purpose when he takes the head, still in its glass case, to the top of the cliff on Widow’s Hill and throws it to the rocks below.

Gerard flings the head over Widows’ Hill. Screenshot by Dark Shadows Before I Die.

Carrie emerges from the darkness the moment after Gerard flings the head into the abyss. He demands to know what she saw and why she is there. She says she saw nothing, and that she followed him to see if he was meeting a girl. He calms down and makes another attempt to be charming. She says that he seems to be himself again. He is happy with this idea.

Gerard takes Carrie back to Rose Cottage. Her governess, Daphne Harridge, is waiting for her there. Daphne says that she will take Carrie back home to the great house on the estate of Collinwood. But then it turns out that Samantha has sent her son Tad, Daphne’s other charge, to stay with Flora at Rose Cottage and that there is no reason Carrie should not stay there as well. Gerard sends Carrie out of the room to say goodnight to Flora.

Gerard takes this as an opportunity to pressure Daphne to go out with him on a date. Daphne has only just met Carrie and may not know about her feelings for Gerard. Nonetheless, she is uncomfortable with the idea of going out with him, partly because Samantha’s sister Roxanne just died, partly because of Gerard’s aggressive manner, and partly because Flora’s son Desmond already forced her to spend some hours socializing with him in the afternoon. She keeps refusing, and he keeps informing her that he will call for her at Collinwood in an hour.

After a hostile interlude with Desmond, Gerard spends some quality time fondling the mask. He then gets very sleepy. He yells down the hall at Carrie, saying he is about to take a nap and asking her to wake him in half an hour. She yells back that she will be glad to. As is customary for men in Collinsport, he lies down on the bed fully clothed, boots and all. He dreams that Carrie wakes him, saying that a pleasant man has come to see him. He opens the door to find a man he has never seen holding the glass case that he had thrown off the cliff. He awakens, and the same scene plays out.

The man is unknown to Gerard, but familiar to longtime viewers. He is Humbert Allen Astredo. In 1968, Astredo played the suave Nicholas Blair, who was introduced as a warlock of unfathomably vast powers. Astredo’s talents as an actor were so considerable that he held our attention for weeks and weeks, keeping us waiting to see what terrible plan Nicholas was pursuing. When it finally became clear that Nicholas was flying blind and that whatever he might come up with to do was going to fail almost immediately, the disappointment was so bitter that he had to be incinerated and dragged back to Hell in front of us. Apparently even that wasn’t sufficient punishment for having disappointed us so thoroughly. When another storyline collapsed early in 1970, they brought Nicholas back for a couple of weeks, just so that they could kill him off again.

In between his two tours of duty as Nicholas, Astredo appeared in the long segment of Dark Shadows set in 1897 as lawyer/ Satanist Evan Hanley. Evan was both a commentary on Nicholas and a great improvement on him. He aspired to become what Nicholas was introduced as already being. That gave him a set of goals and kept us in suspense as to how close he would come to achieving them. When he fell short of his objectives, it was interesting to see what would happen to him and how he would react to it.

We can’t tell who Astredo is today. He might be a third run-through of Nicholas. If so, we can expect that he will strut and preen and tell Gerard that he cannot escape what is in store for him. When Gerard’s personality is erased and James Storm starts playing the evil spirit of the head, Nicholas will become his helpless stooge and wind up in yet another damnation scene. That sounds pretty dismal. But if this is another human aspiring to become a warlock, perhaps he will recapture the spark that Astredo cultivated as Evan. If that happens, Gerard or whatever takes Gerard’s place just might have an associate in whose company he can finally shine brightly enough to become what we had hoped he would be.

Episode 1136: I’m sure that you would be even more prettier

Mad scientist Julia Hoffman sews the severed head of warlock Judah Zachery back on its body, electrifies it with a bolt of lightning, and exclaims to her assistant, Cockney showgirl/ psychic Leticia Faye, that Judah “is alive!” Grayson Hall doesn’t take this line as far over the top as Colin Clive took the original line in the 1931 film Frankenstein, but she and Nancy Barrett are having so much fun with the whole preposterous situation that she doesn’t have to.

Unfortunately, another cast member is stuck with a less enjoyable set of chores today. That is James Storm as seagoing con man Gerard Stiles. Nothing Gerard does makes much sense, the dialogue he speaks while doing it is turgid and pointless, and he starts the episode already in a pose of extreme self-satisfaction that leaves the character nowhere to go emotionally. It’s no wonder he keeps stumbling over his lines. When we watched the episode, my wife, Mrs Acilius, described Gerard’s part as “crappy.” Enough of Mr Storm’s personal charm peeks through to make Gerard just about watchable, but it is no wonder the character did not take off with viewers as other villains had done.

In a mansion known as Rose Cottage, Gerard catches Leticia sneaking out of a room with a wooden box. He demands she tell him what is in the box. She refuses; they scuffle. She has a perfect opportunity to knee him in the groin. Leticia is the sort of downright personality whom one would expect to be used to defending herself in that manner. Moreover, she is under Judah’s power, and he is most insistent she bring him the contents of the box at once. The box itself looks quite sturdy and is admirably suited to banging Gerard on the head until he is unable to follow Leticia out of Rose Cottage. So it is quite disappointing that she leaves her feet on the floor and lets Gerard take the box. Leticia hasn’t had much sleep lately, maybe her reaction time is just down.

Gerard opens the box and finds what the show asks us to accept as a solid gold mask inlaid with precious jewels (it looks like part of a Halloween costume that cost $1.98, but let us put that to one side.) He exclaims that it must be worth a fortune. Leticia asks him to hand it over to her so that she can take it to Braithwaite’s shop in the village to be appraised. Inexplicably, he agrees.

Gerard goes to the great house of Collinwood, where he confronts newly hired governess Daphne Harridge with a demand for her real name. She denies having any other name, and he says there is no record of a Daphne Harridge in the town she told him she came from. She says she lied when she claimed to be from that town, since he is neither her employer nor a member of the Collins family and so it was impertinent of him to question her about her history. That leaves Gerard at a dead end.

The effective master of Collinwood, Quentin Collins, hears a tune being played on the piano in the drawing room. We haven’t heard it before, and we wonder what it could possibly be. The dramatic date is 1840, and the tune is in a post-impressionist style that would be unknown until the 1920s and not popular for decades after that. Quentin finds Gerard at the piano. Gerard points to the sheet music on the piano. Quentin says that the only copy of it belonged to his paramour Joanna Mills, and that other notes apparently from Joanna have turned up in odd places in the last few days. Since Joanna has been dead for almost a year, Quentin finds this troubling.

Gerard declares that “Well, there must be two reasons. Either somebody is deliberately trying to upset you, or Joanna is trying to communicate with you, beyond the grave.” He and Quentin then go on to bicker about Quentin’s reluctance to accept a supernatural explanation. As Mrs Acilius pointed out, the whole matter becomes quite simple once you set aside the supernatural option. Daphne, a woman about whom Quentin knows almost nothing, moved into the house at almost exactly the time the notes started appearing. Since Gerard was just telling Daphne that he suspects she is up to no good, we cannot understand why he does not bring this up to Quentin. I’ve heard actors talk about situations when they froze on stage because the character had no coherent attitude towards the words and actions; it’s a tribute to Mr Storm’s professionalism that he could deliver his dialogue at all today.

Episode 1132: A remarkably modern day woman

In 1968, mad scientist Julia Hoffman, MD, built two Frankenstein’s monsters. Now Julia has traveled back in time to 1840. She and Cockney showgirl/ mentalist Leticia Faye have come under the power of Judah Zachery, a warlock who was beheaded in 1692. Judah’s head and body have been maintaining separate residences ever since, and now he wants them reattached. Julia has given Leticia a list of medical supplies that she will need to complete the operation.

The other day, we heard Quentin Collins and his wife Samantha quarreling about their crappy marriage. Evidently Quentin asked Samantha to agree to a divorce four years ago so that he could marry someone he didn’t hate. Today, we learn that this person’s name was Joanna Mills, that she was a widow when Quentin took up with her, that her landlady Mrs Purdy was her only friend, and that Mrs Purdy identified Joanna’s corpse after she escaped from the insane asylum and drowned herself.

Mrs Purdy shows up at the great house of Collinwood and tells Quentin all of this. He doesn’t know what to make of this news, since he recently received a handwritten note apparently from Joanna. Indeed, immediately after Mrs Purdy leaves Quentin finds another such note.

Quentin talks with Mrs Purdy.

Returning viewers have every reason to believe that the notes are the creations of Daphne Harridge, a young woman whom Quentin just hired to be governess to his son Tad. Daphne keeps writing in her journal that her plan to murder Quentin is coming along nicely. At one point today, she leaves her gun behind in the drawing room where a houseguest finds it. An amazingly poor sense of OpSec is one thing all the most popular characters on Dark Shadows have in common, so we can take it that Daphne will be on the show for a long time.

For her part, Samantha is furious that Quentin has hired Daphne. She has always hired the governesses. It is particularly galling to Samantha that Quentin did not inform her that he had taken that task from her, even though he told the cook that Daphne would be coming. Samantha tries to bring up something she asserted earlier, that Tad is not Quentin’s son but the product of a dalliance she had with a lover. He cuts her off before she can repeat this claim, and tells her she is free to leave the house.

Mrs Purdy is played by Camila Ashland, her third and, alas, final role on Dark Shadows. The others were also one-shots. In #928, Ashland played Mrs Hutchins, a woman the villains hired to lie to Julia. In #997, she was Mrs Duval, landlady to masochistic barmaid Buffie Harrington. Ashland was an extremely distinguished stage actress. She has a lot of trouble with her lines today, but she still manages to get the point across that Mrs Purdy was not at all shocked that Joanna was carrying on an affair with a married man and that she tried her best to get her decent care when her mental health collapsed.

Mrs Purdy wears a bonnet that I believe we have seen before. In the early days of the show, the most frequently mentioned figures in the supernatural back-world behind the action were The Widows, ghosts of women whose young husbands died because of the Collins family’s inhumane management of its whaling fleet. In #266, we learned that The Widows were named Rachel Comstock, Margaret Findley, and Abigail Tolliver. A couple of times we caught glimpses of The Widows, and when we did we always saw one wearing a bonnet just like Mrs Purdy’s.

The ghosts of Collinwood in #126.
The Widows in #266. The one in the middle is wearing the bonnet.

We are now in the era when the Widows would have been alive. I wonder if they dug the bonnet up for the first time since 1967 because in some early stage of the planning for the 1840 segment they were thinking of incorporating a story that would have introduced Rachel, Margaret, and Abigail as living characters.

Episode 1129: Headless body on boundless estate

Vampire Barnabas Collins and mad scientist Julia Hoffman have traveled back in time to 1840. They know that events took place in that year that led to a disaster that destroyed the great house of Collinwood and everyone in it in 1970 and that left the whole estate of Collinwood a deadly, hag-ridden waste in 1995. They hope to find a way to change history.

Today, they discover a woman lying on the ground in the woods. She is Hortense, governess at the great house, and she is horribly injured. At first they think Hortense is dead, but Julia feels her wrist and says, using a bit of Collinsport English we haven’t heard since #672, that she can feel a “pulsebeat.” Hortense manages to speak the words “headless creature” before she dies.

Julia and Barnabas tell Quentin Collins, heir to Collinwood and its acting master, what happened. His reaction makes it clear that he knows what Hortense meant by “headless body.” Later, Barnabas gets Quentin to tell him the truth. His cousin Desmond found a severed head in a shop in Macau and brought it back as a gift for him. The severed head turned out to be that of warlock Judah Zachery, who terrorized the town of Bedford until he was executed in 1692. The head has cropped up again from time to time, most recently in 1803, when it was associated with four brutal slayings known as “The Bedford Atrocities.” Under the head’s influence, Desmond found its body. Now the body is roaming about. The head has also gone missing. Until Quentin heard that the body is still headless, he assumed that Judah’s parts had reconnected themselves. He still thinks they must be hanging around together someplace.

Barnabas and Julia decide that the head and body must be associated with the disaster they want to prevent. They make a note of it. But they have more definite knowledge about a woman called Daphne Harridge. They saw Daphne’s ghost in 1995 and 1970, and got to know her as a living being when she was briefly resurrected in 1970. She was governess at Collinwood in 1840, was killed along with her charges, teens Tad Collins and Carrie Stokes, in 1841, and was a part of the disaster in 1970. When they first arrived in 1840, they were puzzled to find that Hortense was the governess and that no one had heard of Daphne. But Daphne is in Collinsport now, and the governess’ position is vacant. Julia and Barnabas make it their top priority to keep her from becoming governess.

Quentin believes Barnabas and Julia to be his cousins from England (or Philadelphia, it doesn’t seem to make a difference.) He has trusted them with the secret of what he and Desmond have done involving the head. So you might think they would address this problem by trying to persuade him not to hire Daphne. But that doesn’t seem to occur to them. Instead Julia goes to Daphne’s room and tells her she is about to be offered the post of governess at Collinwood and that if she accepts it she will be in terrible danger. In response, Daphne asks Julia who she is and why she is threatening her. Julia tries to explain that she is a friend bringing a warning, but that doesn’t cut any ice. Regular viewers know that Julia is not only a prodigiously skilled and creative liar, but that she also has a magical power of hypnosis that enables her to rewrite people’s memories. With those qualifications, you’d think she could do better than that. When Quentin drops by later and says that Desmond has recommended her to be the next governess, Daphne is startled, but quickly accepts.

The episode ends with a hooded figure walking through the old cemetery north of town. We see the figure from behind as it enters the mausoleum where Barnabas’ family is entombed. The figure opens the secret panel. The camera stays low and does not allow us to see the face of the figure entering the hidden chamber where Barnabas was sealed in a chained coffin when he first became a vampire in the 1790s. When the figure is in position to see that the coffin is not there, the camera pans up and we see that it is wicked witch Angelique. The composition shows that this is supposed to be a big shock. Indeed it would be, had Lara Parker not delivered the opening voiceover, giving away that she is going to be in the episode.

Oh look, it’s Angelique. Screenshot by Dark Shadows Before I Die.

They have ruined many surprises this way. This one is a particular shame. Regular viewers know that Angelique will probably turn up sooner or later, but this is the first time we have seen the character since #978.* Her return is a big deal, and we do have a right to expect the show to be more careful about getting the biggest bang they can out of it.

*Parker played an alternate universe counterpart of Angelique from April to July 1970. She’s been away for 72 episodes.

Episode 1123: The Strange Case of the Pagan Head

Desmond Collins has fallen under the power of a mysterious severed head he brought back from southeastern China. When his mother Flora sees him in the room where he keeps the head in a glass case, he bursts out with inexplicable remarks, such as “An outcast has no friends!” and “I kept telling them! Death was an extension of life! I kept telling them that!” Flora remarks that Desmond hasn’t acted like that since he was in love with a girl named Carson. He then tells her that she’s discovered his secret. He met a pretty girl recently and can’t find her again, and that’s what he’s upset about. This doesn’t explain who it was Desmond told that “Death was an extension of life!” or why it is important to remember either that idea or the notion that “An outcast has no friends,” but it’s the best Flora is going to get, so she settles for it.

Desmond really is trying to reconnect with a pretty girl. Her name is Daphne Harridge, and he finds her today when he goes to the offices of the Collinsport Star to ask for some issues from October 1803, 37 years ago. His cousin, the 57 year old Daniel Collins, told him that the papers were full of stories about a series of murders that took place in and around the town of Bedford in that month, and that a severed head was mentioned in connection with them. Since Daniel also said that the man who was last known to have the head ran off to Macau and died there, Desmond suspects that it is the same head he brought back from that city. Moreover, a man named Ben Stokes recently died in circumstances that strongly remind Daniel of the Bedford Atrocity, and Desmond now knows that the Head has power over him. So he fears the worst.

Desmond is surprised when Daphne answers the door at the offices of the Star. She explains that she needed a job, and she found a respectable one there. She shows him the file with back issues from October 1803. He finds some with stories about the killings in Bedford, and asks permission to sign them out. When he does, she asks if he is making a joke. He has signed his name “Judah Zachery.” He is disconcerted, then claims that he uses that as a pen name for some writing he does.

A headline from an October 1803 edition of the Collinsport Star. Screenshot by Dark Shadows Before I Die.

Earlier, we had seen Daphne at what we now know was her desk at the newspaper office. Daphne was thinking to herself that she really ought to have found a way to pretend to like Desmond when they met yesterday, since he can be useful to her in the objective she has come to Collinsport to pursue. She wondered how she would meet him again. So when he invites her to the house he and Flora share, a mansion known as Rose Cottage, she gladly accepts.

Daphne has dinner with Desmond, Flora, and Quentin Collins. Quentin is Daniel’s son and the heir to his vast fortune. He turned up at the great house of Collinwood the other day, six months after he and his son Tad were washed off the deck of a ship at sea and presumed dead. He and Tad hiked their way back to the States over a circuitous route that took them all through South America, and Quentin got home just in time to congratulate his wife on her remarriage.

Flora has recently taken an avid interest in the occult. She deals a layout of tarot cards to tell Quentin’s fortune. She is horrified by each card in its turn. She asks Quentin if someone close to him died recently. They just had Ben’s funeral and he has been close to the family for decades, but Quentin gets agitated and insists that no one he loves has died, no one at all.

Back in the newspaper office, Daphne writes in a notebook that she has met the man she came to town to kill. Presumably this is a private notebook; it might be embarrassing if that winds up printed in the paper.

Episode 1122: The drama will begin to unfold

A disaster destroyed the great house of Collinwood and everyone in it in 1970. The ghosts of some people who were alive in 1840 were part of this disaster. Vampire Barnabas Collins and mad scientist Julia Hoffman have traveled back in time in hopes of preventing the disaster.

One of the ghosts was that of governess Daphne Harridge. When Julia and Barnabas first arrived in 1840, they were bewildered to find that no one at Collinwood had heard of Daphne. Now, Barnabas has found Daphne skulking about in the woods on the grounds of the estate. He confronts her, and demands she answer a series of questions. Desmond Collins, a cousin of the Collinses who live in the great house, shows up just in time to hear Barnabas threatening to force Daphne to tell him what he wants to know. Desmond asks why he would do that, and Barnabas has no choice but to back down. Desmond and Daphne walk away together.

Barnabas has a habit of introducing himself to his adversaries by declaring that he has come to fight them. He did that when he met the evil Gerard Stiles, whose ghost he saw as the face of the disaster in 1970. But the living Gerard has no idea who Barnabas is. For all Barnabas knows, it might be possible for him to get close enough to Gerard to pick up a great deal of information from him that he can use to reshape the future. Daphne doesn’t recognize him either, but when in the twentieth century he and Julia interacted with her ghost and with a resurrected version of her, Daphne was often helpful to them. Barnabas’ aggressive manner in this scene blows any chance he may have had to build the same kind of relationship in this period. Even worse, when Desmond walks in on the encounter what he sees confirms the suspicions he has already expressed, costing Barnabas another possible ally.

My frustration with Barnabas’ part in this scene drove me to fanfic a few years ago. In a comment on Danny Horn’s post about the episode at his great blog Dark Shadows Every Day, I wrote:

One of my pet peeves is Barnabas’ habit of introducing himself to people as their enemy. He does it with Daphne in this episode, and he did it with Gerard last week. Not only is it irritatingly stupid, but it creates a pacing problem. They establish the enmity right away, then they have nothing to do while we sit around for weeks and weeks waiting for a confrontation. If he’d made an effort to charm Gerard, we could watch that effort crumble, and the last part of its collapse could coincide with their showdown.

The scene where Barnabas meets Daphne calls out for a different sort of fix. Everyone watching the show knows that Barnabas is a vampire, and everyone who saw the cliffhanger at the end of #1121 knows that Daphne is going to be important. So have him do a “Look into my eyes!” bit. Then we are in suspense- will he get useful information? Will he bite her? They show us Desmond approaching, and the suspense shifts- will Desmond catch them in a compromising situation? If he does, will Barnabas kill him? Even if the scene ends up doing as little to advance the plot as the scene they shot in fact does, the result would be an exciting sequence that promises big developments later on.

Comment by “Acilius,” 10 February 2021, on “Episode 1121: The Lost World,” Dark Shadows Every Day, 31 January 2018

In the great house, Julia is having a conversation with Gabriel Collins. She has told the family that she is a medical doctor. Nine more years will pass before Elizabeth Blackwell is admitted to that profession in 1849, making Julia the first woman to practice medicine in the United States. Extraordinary as her claim to be a doctor is, everyone accepts it equably enough. Gabriel says that one of these days Julia will have to see if she can do anything about his legs, which haven’t been able to bear his weight since an accident he had when he was a child. He starts to explain what his brother Quentin did to cause that accident. He is chattering away happily when he suddenly falls silent and drops his teacup. He is stunned to see Quentin entering the room.

Gabriel had thought Quentin was dead. Everyone thought that until a day or two ago, when Quentin returned after an absence of six months. He explained that while it is true that he and his son Tad were washed off the deck of a ship in a storm, they survived and made their way through South America by a highly circuitous route. Julia knows this, and greets Quentin calmly. But no one bothered to tell Gabriel. If that were not enough to tell us where Gabriel ranks in the hierarchy at Collinwood, it is made abundantly clear after Julia excuses herself and leaves the brothers to talk. Quentin says that he always felt guilty about his part in Gabriel’s injury, which is why he has put up with him so much longer than anyone else. But now, even he has had enough of Gabriel’s intolerable personality.

We see Daphne and Desmond sharing one of two circular tables covered with checkered cloths in front of a fireplace. On the wall above the fireplace is a metallic decoration in the shape of an eagle. In the foreground is a bar with a rack of drinking glasses. Longtime viewers know that the tavern in Collinsport was in the eighteenth and nineteenth century known as The Eagle, and that its tables were covered with checkered cloths even in the 1790s.

Daphne and Desmond at The Eagle

Daphne was prominent in the twentieth century segments that led us to 1840, while Desmond was never mentioned. His very existence seems to be omitted from the documents that Barnabas and Julia examined when they were trying to figure out what happened in 1840. So it is clear to us that he doesn’t have a shot with Daphne, but not to him. He’s dialed the charm up to 11, or would have if he weren’t such a grouchy New Englander that the most charming manner he can produce rises to about 4. She won’t answer any of his questions, but finally agrees not to check out of the Collinsport Inn and leave town until tomorrow.

Desmond goes home to a mansion known as Rose Cottage. He has brought a curio from his recent trip to southeastern China, intending it as a gift for Quentin. It is a human head in a glass box. When his mother reacted to the sight of this blasphemous thing with horror, Desmond told her that he was sure it was “a carving of some sort,” not an actual body part, and asserted that there was nothing frightening about it. He has since had second thoughts, though the head keeps waiting for Desmond to look away before it opens its eyes.

Quentin turns up and tells Desmond that he has come for the present he had told him he has for him. Desmond has changed his mind about giving the head to Quentin, so he has to scramble to come up with another present. Finally, he tells Quentin that the present is a couple of books about the occult. Quentin is delighted with them. He says he has been eager to get back into the study of “the lost world that we can’t understand, or even see.” He sits down and starts reading them right there, and Desmond suggests that it is time to go. Quentin is disappointed to have to wait to get home to read the books, but goes anyway.

Barnabas shows up and pesters Desmond about Daphne. Desmond is unimpressed with Barnabas, but does tell him that, contrary to the promise she made at the Eagle, Daphne has checked out of the inn and left no forwarding address. He shoos Barnabas away.

Back at Collinwood, Julia and Barnabas are in the drawing room. The doors to the rest of the house are wide open as they declaim loudly about how they are pretending to be people they are not and dare trust no one with their terrible secrets. Fortunately for them, the only person who overhears them is Daphne, who is sneaking into the house to leave a note in the foyer for Quentin.

Back at Rose Cottage, Desmond is yelling at the head. An image of the head is superimposed over him, and he shows signs of distress. We saw aged retainer Ben Stokes have a similar reaction the other day when the image of the head was superimposed on him; Ben died as a result. Desmond hears a voice telling him that he will follow its commands. We are to take it that he is now possessed by the head.